Gaza activists in Athens 311.
(photo credit: REUTERS)
WASHINGTON – Long before any ship’s bow from the Gaza-bound flotilla has crested
the Mediterranean this summer, the US State Department issued a lengthy
statement criticizing the expedition’s participants and strategy.
RELATED:Flotilla faces serious delays, might sail only next weekGov't on flotilla: We won't be surprised this time
that seek to break Israel’s maritime blockade of Gaza are taking irresponsible
and provocative actions that risk the safety of their passengers,” the
statement, issued by State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland,
Last year, it wasn’t until a melee at sea between the vessels
trying to break Israel’s Gaza blockade and the IDF left nine Turkish activists
dead that the US put out a statement, in that case primarily expressing concern
for the loss of life and the humanitarian situation in Gaza.
this year the US government has the benefit of knowing what a disaster the Free
Gaza flotilla precipitated in the past, and the memory of that encounter is
certainly motivating the State Department to be more proactive.
last year there had been reluctance to delve into the legalities of American
participation in the flotilla, the recent statement, distributed on Friday, gave
a stark warning.
“We underscore that delivering or attempting or
conspiring to deliver material support or other resources to or for the benefit
of a designated foreign terrorist organization, such as Hamas, could violate US
civil and criminal statutes and could lead to fines and incarceration,” Nuland
And where previously quiet conversations had been held to
dissuade the vessels from sailing, Friday’s statement could not have been louder
“We urge all those seeking to provide such assistance to the
people of Gaza to use [existing] mechanisms, and not to participate in actions
like the planned flotilla,” Nuland said.
But such stern US efforts at
dissuasion come not only with the hindsight of the past but with an eye toward
This year, ship bound for Gaza aren’t the only troublesome
threat on the horizon; there’s also the looming possibility of a Palestinian
appeal to the UN General Assembly for a recognition of statehood in
The United States is laboring mightily to prevent the
Palestinians from taking that step, or at the very least to keep the Europeans
from voting in favor of such a unilateral declaration should it be proposed, out
of the belief that without the “moral minority” of the West, such a declaration
would lack serious diplomatic heft.
To that end, US President Barack
Obama outlined a controversial framework for restarting talks between Israelis
and Palestinians in his Middle East speech in May, and has dispatched key aides
to prod both sides toward the table – and to lobby Europeans to back his
suggested model over the Palestinian UN bid.
America opposes a unilateral
declaration at the UN because it doesn’t believe it will lead the parties to the
negotiating table – in fact, it believes that it could instead harden the lines
of each side – and because its close ally Israel is so vehemently against it.
But the effort to derail the Palestinian strategy is also given urgency by
Obama’s own difficult position: he himself called for the UN to endorse a
Palestinian state in 2011 at last year’s opening of the General Assembly,
meaning he would be put in the position of voting against his own vision should
the Palestinians force a vote.
With the stakes so high, the
administration is keen not to have anything to make its job at the UN harder.
And another flotilla fiasco, where the US is put on the spot to defend Israel in
defiance of the demands of much of the international community, would only make
the road to September steeper.
The US, after all, had to use its
considerable influence last year to keep the UN from mandating an investigation
into Israel’s activities along the lines of the infamous Goldstone Report, which
charged that Israel had committed war crimes in its fight against Hamas in the
winter of 2008-2009.
The last thing the United States wants to do is to
expend political chips at the UN during the coming days, when the new flotilla
is expected to arrive off the Gaza coast. That could leave it with a very weak
hand come September.