The first Egyptian reactions to the grad rockets that targeted Eilat were of
flat denial. No fewer than three individuals – a self-proclaimed expert, a
retired general and a military commentator – explained at length that there was
no way the missiles had been launched from Sinai.
One said that
determining what had happened would take time and would require satellite
images; another argued that the Iron Dome system, recently deployed to the Eilat
area, is designed to intercept only projectiles launched from beyond Israel’s
borders — the rockets must have been launched from Israeli territory, he duly
concluded. South Sinai’s governor joined the chorus, rejecting out of hand the
notion that the rockets could have been shot from the peninsula.
be remembered that in December 2010, this governor’s predecessor accused the
Mossad of dispatching a shark to the waters of Sharm e-Sheikh in order to harm
local tourism. A “high ranking army source wishing to remain anonymous” added
that the ongoing investigation had found no indication that the missiles had
originated in Egypt.
A few hours later, perspectives Egyptian views were
shifting, perhaps because a Salafi group had taken responsibility for the
An Egyptian Army spokesman posted a statement on its Facebook
page indicating that a commission of inquiry had been immediately set up to
check the situation on the ground in Sinai.
In the statement, the
spokesman wrote that Egyptian territory had never been and would never be a
threat to neighboring countries.
The presidency followed suit with a
similar communiqué, while another military source indicated that the Egyptian
Defense Minister General Abdel Fattah Alsisi had given orders to raise the state
of alert along the Israeli border to its maximum level.
No one seemed
aware that Iron Dome radars and other installations had tracked the missiles,
and that the likely explanation for the decision not to fire at them was that
such an interception would have taken place in Egyptian airspace.
stage, Israel is unwilling to violate its neighbor’s sovereignty. In Egypt, as
in all Arab countries, denial is the name of the game whenever Israel is
involved. They are never the ones at fault, it seems; it is always the Zionists
or the Jews.
This reality does not make the necessary security
cooperation between Israel and Egypt any easier – even when Egyptian personnel
are at risk – despite being in both countries’ best interests.
join forces to fight the spread of Jihadi terror in the Sinai Peninsula and in
Gaza, a trend which presents a serious threat not just to Israel but also to
Egypt. This is not to say that there is no exchange of information — what
happens after Israel has passed sensitive material to Egypt, however, is
Back in August, Israel warned the former head of
Egyptian security that Islamist militants were planning to attack an army post,
but he refused to take action, and 16 Egyptian soldiers were slaughtered. He was
Conversely, deploying the Iron Dome to Eilat 10 days ago may well
have been the result of information received about a plot to fire rockets, but
if this was the case, there is no indication that the Egyptians did anything at
their end to prevent the rocket fire.
Sinai is for all intents and
purposes a war zone. The traditional distrust felt by the peninsula’s Beduin
towards the central government has only been exacerbated by years of neglect.
Nothing has been done to improve the lot of the population; there are no
workplaces, there is no meaningful development and not even a decent school
Hamas found a willing ally in the Beduin – ready to
transport arms and ammunition, rockets included.
Much of this contraband
originates from Iran, traveling through Sudan and mainland Egypt to Sinai and to
the Gaza Strip.
Other Jihadi terror organizations loosely linked to
al-Qaida have followed suit, setting up local cells and paying Beduin handsomely
for their assistance.
Mubarak’s fall and the subsequent decline of the
central authority have only made matters worse in Sinai.
his removal from power, security forces left the area, turning Sinai into a
drug-smuggling haven as well as a major artery for Africans seeking a new life
With the fall of Gaddafi, Libyan munitions joined the flow.
And still nothing has been done to develop the peninsula and improve conditions
for its inhabitants.
Last October the government took steps to allow the
purchase and rental of land by Beduin who could demonstrate Egyptian citizenship
for themselves and their parents and that they did not hold a second
nationality. The ink on that piece of legislation was barely dry when the
defense minister issued a decree forbidding the purchase of land on a strip 5
kilometers deep along Egypt’s border with Israel and with Gaza.
done in order to exercise better control of the area, prevent terrorist
infiltration and supervise the tunnels moving contraband to Gaza.
Beduin were bitterly disappointed: They demanded that the decree be rescinded
and threatened civil disobedience. Intense negotiations are ongoing, but so far
no solution has been found, and violence could break out at any
There is yet another conflict brewing in Sinai, this one between
the Beduin and the Muslim Brothers.
The former supreme guide of the
Brotherhood, Muhammad Mehdi Akef, told the Kuwait daily Al Jarida last week that
all Beduin are collaborators: One third collaborate with state security
services, another with army intelligence, and the final third spies for Israel.
(He did not mention collaboration with Jihadist and Hamas
Hundreds of angry Beduin demonstrated in front of Brotherhood
headquarters in Sinai, threatening to turn it to rubble unless Akef
More demonstrations, as well as a civil suit for slander, are
It can hardly be expected that Beduin will help the central
government fight terror, considering so many of them earn their livelihoods by
smuggling drugs, people or arms on behalf of those terror groups.
then is Israel to do? Thousands of armed terrorists in dozens of groups
operating in the peninsula are openly threatening Israel’s security, and yet it
is greatly limited in the measures it can adopt against them.
indeed a measure of intelligence- sharing between the Israel and her southern
neighbor, but without increased levels of cooperation — similar to those during
the Mubarak years — such efforts will remain ineffective.
A few months
ago the Egyptian army announced it was launching an all-out campaign against
terror in Sinai.
Yet terrorists continue to operate in broad daylight,
attacking police stations, setting up road blocks and targeting army patrols.
Last week one policeman was killed and another injured by terrorists or
Egyptian president Mohamed Morsi has no meaningful contact
with Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu. The Brothers do not speak with Israel.
Only last week, in an interview with Al Jazeera Arabic, Morsi couldn’t even
bring himself to utter Israel’s name, saying of the limited contact Egypt and
Israel do maintain that “even enemies occasionally speak.”
cooperation on both sides of the border will put an end to the state of
lawlessness in the peninsula, but with the Muslim Brothers at Egypt’s helm, it
does not look like this will happen anytime soon.
The writer is a former
ambassador to Egypt.