A power struggle usually ends with winners and losers. If a new religious textbook critical of Western culture is any indication of who is winning the role of guardian of young minds in Saudi Arabia, then Islamic conservatives are the clear victors.
RELATED:Saudi King revokes 10-lash sentence for female driver Saudis to give PA $200m. to help ease financial crisis
In what amounts to a rebuke of a scholarship program under the aegis of none other than King Abdullah himself that sends thousands of young Saudis to foreign universities, a new secondary school textbook called Hadith argues that Western culture exposes students to corruption.
“The conservatives have the upper hand and have made sure that it’s their voice that says what is permitted in Islam,” Ehsan Ahrari, a Middle East analyst based near Washington DC, told The Media Line “The conservatives have the loudest voice in making a persuasive argument within the Saudi context. Saudi Arabia is truly concerned about modernization in its educational institution, but even the king doesn’t know how to deal with it.”
The publication of the book comes at a sensitive time for Saudi Arabia as it struggles to scrub its textbooks of derogatory language of other religions and cultures. The Ministry of Education has made progress to eliminate some passages, including controversial definitions of jihad.
More than 100,000 Saudis have obtained King Abdullah Foreign Scholarship
to pursue studies in universities in professional fields such as
medicine, computer science, engineering courses and administration and
finance. About 30 percent study in the US, 15% in Britain, 11% in Canada
and 8% in Australia. Only about 6% study in a Muslim country, Egypt.
Saudi Arabia has the largest number of citizens studying aboard of any
country in the world.
The textbook, which warns students of democratic countries’ attempts to
Westernize Muslim countries by advancing the United Nations’ human
rights agenda, has received little attention in the media, where
restrictive laws passed in response to the Arab Spring. The Saudi
government can levy fines and jail sentences for criticizing government
As a result, few Saudis are willing to publicly criticize for the record
the Ministry of Education. Religious conservatives, Ahrari says, are
taking advantage of the chilling effect of those laws to broaden their
But the book has lit up the social media with complaints – mostly
anonymous – that politics have no place in teaching hadith, sayings
attributed the Prophet Muhammad. The authors are accused of attempting
to politicize Islam by slipping criticism of the West into religious
texts just as students are preparing to enter foreign universities.
Saudis have also expressed bewilderment that the Ministry of Higher
Education, which administers the scholarship program, and the Ministry
of Education, which published Hadith, do not have a shared strategic
However, Hadith has brought renewed scrutiny to how the ministry vets
textbooks that contain political opinion. The controversy also renews
focus on how much influence Saudi conservatives wield at a time when
Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood and the Islamic Ennahda Party in Tunisia are
also flexing their political muscle.
The textbook details the “risks” scholarship students face. “A lot of
them [student] have returned laden with the spirit of the West, breathe
with its lungs and think with its mentality,” the book states. “They
echo their Orientalist teachers in their own land and spread their ideas
and theories with deep belief, increasing enthusiasm and eloquence so
they become a burden on their society.”
“The percentage of those who survive from this influence is a very little one,” the book’s authors say.
Another section in Hadith, entitled “Westernization,” targets the UN.
The section characterizes the international organization as a tool for
“dominating” Western powers to apply political pressure on Muslim
countries to adopt more aggressive human rights legislation. The West,
the textbook argues, uses “the United Nations, the Security Council and
its different committees, on weak countries, especially the Islamic
ones. This is done for the sake of westernization under slogans such as
reform, democracy, pluralism, liberation and human rights, in particular
those related to women and religious minorities.”
In fact, some of the views expressed in Hadith are widely held by Saudis.
Maha A., a 33-year-old Jeddah native and university student studying in
Newcastle, England, says the UN entry in the book is legitimate. She
points to the UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of
Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) as meddling in the Kingdom’s
affairs and with sharia, or Islamic law. Saudi Arabia ratified CEDAW in
2000. “I have no problems with the way the United Nations is portrayed
in the book,” she told The Media Line.
The schoolbook also warns of Western attempts to subvert Islamic culture
by distributing “immorality” through the media. It considers the media
tools to advocate western values.
Turki Al-Dakheel, a journalist and presenter on Al-Arabiya television, complained in a column in the Arabic-language daily Al-Watan
that the textbook’s “extremist” portions are not consistent with the
changes taking place in the international community and in Saudi
“The same educational institutes that send students abroad also
criticize the scholarship [program],” Dakheel argues. “We should take
out the mentality of disagreement from our curriculum in order to
protect our students from being politicized or being slaves to one
Ahrari, the Washington-based analyst, told The Media Line that the
book’s content is less a challenge to King Abdullah and more of “classic
bureaucratic” infighting in the Ministry of Education
A Saudi Ministry of Education official, speaking on the condition of
anonymity because of the sensitive nature of the textbook, agreed. He
told The Media Line that there are two factions in the ministry
struggling to implement their ideology: Western-educated liberals and
Many of the ministry’s decision-makers hold postgraduate degrees in
education from the US and Britain. These supervisors often square off
with mid- and upper-level managers educated in Islamic studies from Imam
Mohammed Bin Saud University in Riyadh and other Saudi universities.
“There is a great debate between conservatives and liberals. The
conservatives are in the minority, but they are very active,” says the
official, although he notes the ministry’s policy requires moderation in
The infighting is so intense, he says, that the ministry recently began
publishing school textbooks without authors’ names to prevent
accusations of extremism. Yet the anonymously authored books have also
led to the lack of accountability within the ministry’s ranks for
authors failing to adhere to moderation guidelines.
One 22-year-old Riyadh student studying in Britain says there is little
merit in warning scholarship holders of the dangers in the West.
“Saudi students are already asked to attend a two-week course on Western
culture. The scholarship program selects the highest qualified students
to go abroad. If a student is weak in religion and cultural values, he
won’t be studious and he won’t be allowed in the program,” Muhammad A.
told The Media Line.
But the student also says that human rights issues advocated by the UN
are consistent with the pillars of sharia. “Sharia talks of human rights
and it’s no different than the United Nations’ human rights. It’s
compatible, and there are no negative effects on Saudi Arabia,” he says.