A Beduin man rides a horse in al-Arakib 311 (R).
(photo credit: REUTERS/Amir Cohen)
The courts announced on Sunday that the Beersheba Magistrate’s Court ordered the
Defense Ministry and the Israel Lands Authority to pay Israeli Beduin Ali
Glida’an NIS 853,561 for physical, emotional and other harm when he was injured
by part of an exploding IDF cluster bomb while herding camels.
decision, issued on Wednesday, said the Defense Ministry and the ILA were
negligent in failing to properly warn civilians and keep them out of the area of
an IDF base near Sde Boker, a security area which posed heightened
Glida’an’s left leg and right arm were injured in the August 1,
2003 blast, which also disfigured and scarred his entire body.
companion, Abu Moslam, helped Glida’an get to the IDF base, from which he was
transferred to Soroka University Medical Center in Beersheba.
at Soroka for almost seven weeks, until September 18, 2003.
held that the Defense Ministry and the ILA’s testimony showed they knew that
local Beduin used the area for herding camels, but that relevant IDF officials
had not taken the necessary steps to protect them.
In fact, Gilda’an
testified in 2012 that it was only in 2010-2011 that a warning was placed in the
area to prevent incidents such as his own.
The defendants had argued that
civilians in the area were responsible for acquiring maps of the security
The court rejected this argument, calling it
The defendants also said that Glida’an had entered the area
knowing it was dangerous and with intent to steal scrap metal.
found there was insufficient proof of this argument, while also finding proof
that the defendants knew their signage in the area was weak and that they did
not repair broken or stolen signs quickly enough.
The decision also noted
that the entire security area is spread out over a wide area of 100
The IDF Spokesman’s Office said it had nothing to say about