October 18 marks two years since the prisoner exchange for kidnapped soldier
Gilad Schalit. On that day, our daughter Malki was murdered a second
That is how we felt when Ahlam Tamimi was freed along with 1,023
other terrorists in the deal struck to rescue Schalit from Hamas.
years earlier, Tamimi chose the target, transported the bomb and led her
accomplice by the arm to Jerusalem’s Sbarro restaurant where she instructed him
to detonate the 10 kg. of explosives he carried on his back. Fifteen children,
women and men, among them our precious Malki, perished in the inferno. On this
day in 2011, our prime minister allowed Tamimi to return triumphantly to her
home in Jordan.
A self-confessed, convicted, unrepentant mass murderer,
sentenced to 16 life terms, Tamimi was included in the deal despite our pleas to
Binyamin Netanyahu that her name be removed from the list. In our letters, we
reminded him of an interview in which Tamimi smiled broadly upon learning that
she had murdered eight children, several more than she had presumed.
Israelis are aware of the letters that my husband and I and several other
victims sent our prime minister over the last three years imploring him to meet
us. Not once has he, or his office, responded.
Following the Schalit
deal, Netanyahu announced that he had written to the families of the victims of
terror. His office insisted that “many” such letters were delivered to the post
office. Neither we nor any other such families – and we have asked dozens – ever
received such a letter.
Given the scant media attention, not many know
that last year our prime minister allowed Tamimi’s fiancé, also a murderer
released in the Schalit deal, to leave the West Bank in order to marry her and
settle in Jordan.
This was contrary to an explicit written condition of
the fiancé’s release prohibiting him from ever exiting the West
Once again, our pleas – both written and by phone – that the
permission be refused, were ignored.
In August 2013, it was announced
that 104 prisoners would be released in three tranches to jump-start renewed
negotiations with the PA. The Shin Bet’s director Yoram Cohen warned at the
time: “Their release will damage security, both in terms of immediate threat to
public safety and in terms of an erosion of deterrence.”
Then last month,
Al-Hayat reported that Israel had agreed to release a further 250 convicts.
Presumably, Netanyahu sees these as easy concessions to make to Mahmoud Abbas
and Barack Obama. After all, no outrage has emanated from the 86 percent of
Israeli Jews who, according to a poll, strongly oppose their being set
The latest media buzz is that a third intifada is brewing. There
has been a sharp jump in the number of terror attacks in the West Bank: from 68
in August to 104 in September.
This week we learned of the discovery of a
1.7-km. “abduction tunnel” constructed by Hamas. Eighteen meters underground,
the Hamas construction penetrated some 400 meters into Israel. The news sent
shock waves throughout the country.
A survey published by the Palestinian
Center for Public Opinion last month found that 58% of Palestinians expect a
third intifada to erupt if an agreement is not reached with the Israelis during
the current negotiations. With 70% of Palestinians and 80% of Israelis are
certain the talks will fail, a new intifada looks, at the very least, highly
Yet our serial releaser-of-murderers, Netanyahu, is immutable and
Even objections from seven right wing cabinet ministers
fizzled out almost as soon as they were uttered. The “settlement candy” that
Netanyahu is wont to dole out after each release no doubt buys the Right’s
Potential killers are flush with the confidence that if caught
they will be freed shortly afterward.
There is one aspect of the releases
that has been glossed over even by their opponents: Netanyahu’s usurpation of
He has discarded not only court sentences but, in certain
cases – including our Malki’s murderer – explicit judicial recommendations that
the defendants never be included in any deals.
The foundations of our
democracy are being undermined.
Oddly, Netanyahu himself best expressed
the dangers that his releases pose. In a recent “open letter” posted on his
website, he addressed his constituents after announcing the release of the 104
prisoners. “This is an incredibly difficult decision,” he wrote. “It hurts the
bereaved families, it hurts all of the Israeli people and it hurts me very much.
It clashes with the most important principle, the principle of
Of course, those words only make his decision to pursue these
releases more confounding.
When the world’s democracies are unified in
battling Islamist terrorism, Israel – a prime target for terrorists – is looking
askance at its own terrorist enemies. Once an exemplar of counter terrorism
strategy, Israel has, thanks to Netanyahu, become a terror-enabler.
the victims of terror who feel the pain of releases of terrorists like a knife
stab, have been left to battle this alone.
The first tranche of the 104
prisoners was transported home in the dead of night.
government is keen to hush and hide this outrage. We must not allow it to slip
under the radar any longer.
Frimet Roth is a freelance writer in
Jerusalem. Her daughter Malki was murdered at the age of 15 in the Sbarro
restaurant bombing (2001). With her husband, Arnold, she founded the Malki
Foundation (www.kerenmalki.org). It provides concrete support for Israeli
families of all faiths who care at home for a special-needs child.