Church of the Nativity siege 370.
(photo credit: REUTERS)
With his recent segment for 60 Minutes, CBS News reporter Bob Simon has once
again stoked the perennial debate over why so many native Palestinian Christians
have been leaving the Holy Land in recent decades. Sadly, he addressed this
important issue with a very superficial brand of journalism.
relied mainly on one local Palestinian cleric – notorious Israel-basher Rev.
Mitri Raheb – to single out the “Israeli occupation” as the scapegoat for this
Christian flight. There was no need to dig deeper, since Simon knew the report
was sure to be a sensation from the moment Israeli ambassador Dr. Michael Oren
caught wind of the production and intervened with his bosses at CBS
If Bob Simon had truly wanted to know why Arab Christians have been
fleeing in droves from Palestinian areas, he should have asked those émigrés now
living in Toronto, Sydney and Santiago. Because that is where the majority of
Palestinian Christians now reside – in dispersed communities in Canada, Chile,
Australia, Germany, the United States and elsewhere.
The disturbing truth
is that more than 60 percent of the Arab Christians born in Palestinian areas
over the past several generations now live abroad. Yet the same holds true for
Lebanese Christians, as a similar 60% of their beleaguered community now live in
Indeed, there has been a widening Christian exodus from
all the surrounding Arab countries, with Iraq’s ancient Assyrian Christian
community collapsing from 1.5 million to as few as 250,000 since the Second Gulf
War commenced in 2003. The Coptic Church in Egypt is also losing tens of
thousands of parishioners in the wake of the Arab Spring.
So it is
indisputable that Arab Christians are fleeing all across the Middle East, and
surely the Israeli occupation is not to blame. Rather, this flight has been
primarily due to local conflicts and the rise of Islamic militancy, as noted by
Ambassador Oren, and the Palestinian Christians are no exception to this trend.
The lone exception, in fact, happens to be the State of Israel, the only place
in the entire region where the community of Arab Christians is growing and where
Arab Christians are afforded their democratic rights.
Palestinian clerics insist that Muslims and Christians would co-exist in perfect
harmony if not for the Jews and their settlements. That, sadly, is a living
portrait of a people in denial. How else to explain that Palestinian Christian
flight from the Holy Land predates the “occupation” by decades?
the last British census in 1948 recorded 29,000 Arab Christians living in
Jerusalem, while the first Israeli census in eastern Jerusalem in 1967 found
only 11,000. That means two-thirds of the Arab Christian population had fled
during the 19 years of the Jordanian occupation of east Jerusalem.
real root of the current exodus actually lies in the historic interplay between
Christians, Jews and Muslims in the Middle East ever since the Islamic conquests
began in the seventh century. The region’s Christians and Jews became dhimmis –
suppressed minorities living under Muslim dominance. They could keep their faith
but had to accept second-class status. To survive, both communities adopted a
code of silence which dictated that they never challenge the system or say
anything bad about Islam in public.
This system of dhimmitude basically
held until modern times. The Crusades may have brought temporary relief for some
Christians, but only terror for the Jews.
When Ottoman rule over the
Middle East began to wane, the dynamic finally began to change. The Great Powers
of Europe moved into the region, each concluding deals with the Sultanate in
Istanbul to provide protection to various imperiled Christian denominations.
Western missionaries also brought with them schools, hospitals and other modern
With their better education and job skills, Arab Christians
became more mobile and many began to migrate to the West to escape the prison of
Islam. Thus the modern-day Christian exodus began.
Meanwhile, the Zionist
movement arose with a dream of restoring Jewish sovereignty back in their
ancient homeland. Israel’s emergence in 1948 challenged the system of
Muslim dominance over Christians and Jews, an achievement the Arab world has
never truly accepted.
For many Christians in the Middle East, the rebirth
of Israel actually stands as a light and model of freedom from Muslim tyranny.
But for Palestinian Christians, the conflict that seeks to destroy the Jewish
state has been too close for comfort. They are powerless to end it and
struggling to survive.
Thus many Palestinian Christian leaders have taken
to patriotically waving the flag of Palestinian nationalism higher than even
their Muslim neighbors, in the hope such loyalty to the cause will safeguard
their flocks. They rail against the Israeli occupation and the settlements as
the reason for their dwindling presence. The checkpoints and security barrier
may create hardships for them, but they are not the core reason why proud
Christian families who have weathered many turbulent centuries here are now
pulling up roots.
We must all understand that they are employing an
ancient survival mechanism ingrained through centuries of Muslim oppression.
Unable to name the real culprit, Palestinian Christians often deflect Muslim
anger away from themselves by directing it at the Jews. Meantime, Ambassador
Oren is giving voice to the things they cannot say.The writer is media
director for the International Christian Embassy Jerusalem.