'The Genius of Israel': How we became the 'Comeback Nation' - review

Showing resilience and unity, facing foes in the South (Hamas), the North (Hezbollah), northeast (Syrian militias), east (West Bank violence), and afar (Houthis), Israel, a nation of nine million, uses grit, creativity, technology, and cool-headed focus to defeat our enemies, who are backed by many of the world’s 1.9 billion Muslims and oil-rich Arab states.

Originally, its focus was the internal dissension over the attack on democracy, as the subtitle indicates – “The Surprising Resilience of a Divided Nation in a Turbulent World.” The new book, based on interviews with 100 Israelis, explains “why Israel has shown surprising resilience against many trends that have been sapping affluent societies of their health and vitality. …Israel shows there is nothing inevitable about decline and despair. There is a way to live with, and even thrive in, an age of rapid change and uncertainty.”

Israel is a young country, and its young people are full of creative energy. The median age in Europe is 41.3 years. Europe feels old, acts old.

Israel’s median age is a dozen years younger: 29. And Israel remains youthful; total fertility (number of children per woman) exceeds three, while in Europe, in most countries it is below replacement. An Israeli demographer quoted by Senor and Singer notes that in terms of having children, “Israel is operating in a completely different dimension than all other developed countries.”

Senor and Singer note a distressing fact. According to the Edelman Trust Barometer, a survey done in 28 wealthy countries showed that people in more than half (15) say their country is more divided than in the past. And fewer than a third say they would help those they disagreed with politically. This is not the case in Israel.

Sammy Smooha, a scholar of comparative ethnic relations who has researched the internal divisions in Israeli society, observes that “in Israel, contribution to the public good is still an ever-present demand. Israelis are expected to take the national interest into consideration, not just to cater to their private careers and kin.” Call-ups for army reserve duty exceeded 100% after October 7, with many showing up who were not even called.

Many nations have grown wealthy through free competition and capitalism. The basic tenet of capitalism is the right (obligation?) of the individual to accumulate income and wealth, with a focus on the individual. Israel was born with a socialist culture – and it lingers, despite major efforts to stamp it out. The well-being of the nation counts for a lot in Israel. This explains in part the massive near year-long protest movement against efforts to weaken democracy.

Author Paul Johnson, a Christian who has written wisely about Jews, noted that “Judaism has managed a delicate balance between individual rights and collective responsibility.” This echoes the concept of the Roman writer Seneca, who wrote that “if [a person] wants to live for his own benefit, he must also live for the benefit of others.”

Senor and Singer quote author Yossi Klein Halevi, who wrote: “Israel works on the basis of two essential social units: The family…and even stronger is the chevreh, which functions as almost a super family.” Chevreh means friends from high school, youth groups, university, army, and work. Many Israelis have lifelong friends from kindergarten days.

According to the Pew Research Center, a 2019 opinion poll asked, “What aspect of your life do you currently find fulfilling or satisfying?” Some 69% of Israelis answered “family,” while one-third said “career.”

“Israeli society is like a very strong rubber band,” Senor and Singer write. “However stretched it becomes, there are strong forces pulling it back together.” Israeli society has been supremely stretched since November 2022. It has bounced back amazingly.

Jews love to argue. The Talmud is one long debate – 2,711 pages’ worth. Jewish People Policy Institute president Yedidia Stern, when asked what makes Israel work, responded: “The disputes mentality. It is very Jewish. It is in our blood. It’s one of the advantages that Israeli society has, compared to others.” Out of fierce arguments emerge strong creative ideas – ideas that in innovative medical devices, for instance, have saved millions of lives.

After marrying and making aliyah, I did shortened army service and 30 years of reserve duty. I can attest that the IDF changed my life. I met, ate with, and trained with people I would never have encountered in university life. I became an Israeli after donning baggy khaki pants and shirt.

Senor and Singer note: “Swapping a lengthy and challenging military service for university studies profoundly changes the experience of growing up in Israel, the formative decade of young adulthood, and the values of society that guide people throughout the rest of their lives.”

The late UK chief rabbi Jonathan Sacks summed up the genius of Israel best in a sermon. “This one tiny people,” he wrote, “survived tragedies that would have spelled the end of any other people: The destruction of two Temples, the Babylonian and Roman conquests, the expulsions, persecutions, and pogroms of the Middle Ages, the rise of antisemitism in 19th-century Europe, and the Holocaust.

“It is truly astonishing,” he concluded, “that after each cataclysm, Judaism renewed itself, scaling new heights of achievement.”

And that is precisely what Israel is focused on doing at the present time. ■

Here are some of the life-changing and life-saving innovations developed by Israeli genius and used worldwide: