Weizmann, US researchers create analytical model to assess soot's effect on climate

Study shows particles from burning forests and fuels can cause both warming and cooling of environment.

soot 224.88 (photo credit: Courtesy)
soot 224.88
(photo credit: Courtesy)
Soot from forest fires, the burning of cheap industrial fuels and other incomplete combustion of hydrocarbons does not necessarily cause global cooling. Contrary to what scientists have thought, soot can also, under certain circumstances, cause warming of the environment. Scientists at the Weizmann Institute of Science in Rehovot, the University of Maryland and the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration have created the first analytical model that puts all factors together to show when sooty aerosols rising into the clouds will heat things up and when they'll cool them off. Their article on soot and climate will appear in Friday's issue of the prestigious journal Science. Tons of soot are released into the air annually as forest fires burn from California and the Amazon to Siberia and Indonesia. Climate scientists have generally assumed that the main effect of smoke on climate is cooling, as the floating particles can reflect some solar energy back to space as well as increasing cloud size and life span. But this new research will apparently cause them to rethink soot's role in shaping the Earth's climate. An accurate model of the intricate relationship between clouds and aerosols has been a key missing piece in the picture of human-induced climate change. The scientists believe their findings may help both climate modelers and policy-makers to understand the true climatic consequences of burning trees or sooty industrial fuels. Soot and other airborne particles - known collectively as aerosols - rise into the atmosphere, where they interact with clouds. Understanding what happens when the two meet is extremely complicated, in part because clouds are highly dynamic systems that both reflect the sun's energy back into space, cooling the upper atmosphere, and trap heat underneath, warming the lower atmosphere and the Earth's surface. Aerosols, in turn, can have both heating and cooling effects on clouds. On the one hand, water droplets form around the aerosol particles, and these may extend the cloud cover. On the other hand, particles, especially soot, absorb the sun's radiation, stabilizing the atmosphere and thus reducing cloud formation. Dr. Ilan Koren and Hila Afargan of the Weizmann Institute's environmental sciences and energy research department, together with American colleagues, tested their model on data from the Amazon, finding it reflected the true situation on the ground so accurately they could rule out the possibility that random changes in cloud cover - rather than aerosols from burning forests - were at work. They reported that adding small quantities of aerosols into a clean environment can indeed produce a net cooling effect. As more and more particles enter the cloud layer, however, the effect progressively switches from the cooling to the heating mode. The researchers also found that the extent of the original cloud cover is important: A completely overcast sky prevents the sun's rays from reaching the aerosols, so the result may be more cooling of the atmosphere and the Earth's surface. But the larger the ratio of open sky to clouds, the more aerosol particles absorb radiation, thus hastening the heating of the remaining cloud cover, reducing cloud cover and heating the system.