The UK, the Left and anti-Semitism: Signs of change?

There may be positives coming out of this debate that will, over time, mean that perceptions of anti-Semitism and arguments about how best to confront it will change.

By SIMON JOHNSON
Simon Johnson (photo credit: Courtesy)
Simon Johnson
(photo credit: Courtesy)
RECENT WEEKS have seen an unprecedented level of scrutiny of anti-Semitism in the Labour Party. Numerous reported incidents have led to two inquiries on the subject, and some high-profile suspensions. None more so than that of former mayor of London Ken Livingstone for some disgraceful comments alleging Hitler was a Zionist.
The situation has undoubtedly affected the relationship between the party and the UK’s Jewish communities. The fact that large parts of the party’s first report on anti-Semitism were kept from public view by its National Executive Committee hardly inspired confidence.
It is important to note that the community has historically had a good relationship with Labour and we retain many friends in the party. That being so, the political Left is no stranger to anti-Semitism. The current wave of scrutiny has meant that, at last, we are able to shine a light on issues that have gone unnoticed – or simply ignored – for a generation.
There may be positives coming out of this debate that will, over time, mean that perceptions of anti-Semitism and arguments about how best to confront it will change. We have already seen the emergence of the Jewish Labour Movement as a force within the party, and many Jewish and other supportive MPs and local government councilors are being given a proper hearing.
The incidents could be a defining moment for left-wing politics globally. Britain’s Labour Party is one of the world’s more successful and long-standing left-wing parties ‒ one that many will be watching closely to see how it acts on this issue. The current crisis may have influence on left-wing discourse around the world, including Israel.
We may get widespread acceptance that the word “Zionist” or “Zio” as a term of abuse is anti-Semitic. We may be able to secure acceptance that the use of anti-Semitic tropes in criticism of Israel ‒ such as of global control, manipulation of power and blood libels ‒ are anti-Semitic. Holocaust equivalency and denial also can be anti-Semitic and should have no place in civilized political discourse.
The underlying issue may well be a denial of anti-Semitism on the left of politics, and if the inquiries in the Labour Party lead to that issue being confronted and addressed, that will be a constructive outcome.
If these inquiries are open, transparent and, if their conclusions are published and recommended action is implemented, then confidence in the Labour Party among the community will start to rebuild.