Sir, – Gershon Baskin (“Hamas-Fatah reconciliation: Opportunity or disaster?,” Encountering Peace, May 3) poses 17 basic questions regarding the PA/Hamas unity agreement. Then, without reliable answers, he recommends that Israel strengthen the PA prior to Palestinian elections by immediately expressing its intention to make peace while accepting virtually all Palestinian demands.Following that course of action could threaten Israel’s long-term survival.Far from strengthening the PA, it would suggest that only fear of Hamas had forced Israel to capitulate. Even worse, if Hamas wins the election, Israel will find itself bound to an agreement with a terrorist organization sworn to the country’s destruction.One single question must be answered before any others can be asked: Does Hamas acknowledge the right of the Jewish state to exist in peace? If the answer is yes, then negotiations with a unified Palestinian leadership can begin. If the answer is no, then all the negotiations in the world would be pointless.The Palestinian people will have an opportunity to express their preferences at the ballot box. If they select Hamas, they will have forfeited any claim to a peaceful resolution and Israel should no longer be expected to assist in their state-building efforts. Certainly, no agreement should be signed until the election results are known.EFRAIM A. COHEN Zichron Ya’acov
May 6: Palestinian voting
The Palestinian people will have an opportunity to express their preferences at the ballot box.
Sir, – Gershon Baskin (“Hamas-Fatah reconciliation: Opportunity or disaster?,” Encountering Peace, May 3) poses 17 basic questions regarding the PA/Hamas unity agreement. Then, without reliable answers, he recommends that Israel strengthen the PA prior to Palestinian elections by immediately expressing its intention to make peace while accepting virtually all Palestinian demands.Following that course of action could threaten Israel’s long-term survival.Far from strengthening the PA, it would suggest that only fear of Hamas had forced Israel to capitulate. Even worse, if Hamas wins the election, Israel will find itself bound to an agreement with a terrorist organization sworn to the country’s destruction.One single question must be answered before any others can be asked: Does Hamas acknowledge the right of the Jewish state to exist in peace? If the answer is yes, then negotiations with a unified Palestinian leadership can begin. If the answer is no, then all the negotiations in the world would be pointless.The Palestinian people will have an opportunity to express their preferences at the ballot box. If they select Hamas, they will have forfeited any claim to a peaceful resolution and Israel should no longer be expected to assist in their state-building efforts. Certainly, no agreement should be signed until the election results are known.EFRAIM A. COHEN Zichron Ya’acov