GERSHON HARRIS Hatzor HaglilitDefining a columnSir, – Although I may not agree with him, I have considered Shmuley Boteach a careful writer.So his personal comment while discussing the late co-founder of Apple (“Lessons from the brutal truth about Steve Jobs,” Comment & Features, November 15) about being “orders of magnitude less successful than he (as indeed I am)...” surprised me.What could possibly be Boteach’s definition of success? He may well have meant less financially successful, but he didn’t say that. Freudian slip maybe, but nurturing relationships and striving to leave behind a good name define success in life.Each of us can strive in some way to fulfill the purpose we have been uniquely assigned. We can dedicate our energies toward attaining these goals. But measuring one’s success against that of another on the money scale is delusive and defeating.PESACH GOODLEY Telz StoneSir, – The topic of his column is Steve Jobs, but at the end, Shmuley Boteach segues into what has become a favorite for him of late – US politics. Which begs the question: What qualifies him to be an expert on US politics? Boteach was presumably given his column based on his unique niche as an Orthodox rabbi willing to talk candidly about sex, and on the knowledge and experience he has in that area. Yet he engages in the time-honored but questionable custom practiced by many a rabbi, that of using his bully pulpit to give weight to political views about which he is no more knowledgeable than any layperson.In this column, Boteach argues that Jimmy Carter – intelligent but ineffectual – proves that being smart doesn’t necessarily lead to being a good president.This might be true. But having worked at Oxford, the rabbi surely knows it doesn’t prove the inverse, that lack of intelligence is an asset for a potential president.On the contrary, common sense dictates that, all other things being equal, we want the leader of the most powerful nation to be well-versed in the complex issues affecting the US and the world.Boteach’s belief that for GOP hopeful Rick Perry, surrounding himself with “really bright people” is a perfectly good substitute for intelligence, is a case of deja-vu: The exact same argument was made for then-candidate George W. Bush, another Texas governor with a lackluster grasp of national issues. (And we all know how that presidency worked out.) Using Boteach’s own rabbinic advice – that we refrain from overly blunt and hurtful remarks – I encourage him to continue writing about those issues on which he is an expert!ERIC SOMMER OranitOne man’s Top 10Sir, – Regarding “EU ministers divided over strike on Iran” (November 15), the following are the top 10 reasons why bombing that country is moronic at best: 10. The Israeli intelligence services are dead-set against the idea.9. Experts in field believe that, if successful, it would delay the program by only two years.8. Intelligence estimates say 100,000 missiles are now on line, including many with advanced systems and enhanced range and accuracy, not only in Iran but also in Gaza, Lebanon and Syria.7. Israel can expect a missile barrage on its major cities for 40 days and 40 nights.6. Israeli commanders have woefully underestimated enemy resolve and capability over the past five years.5. As proven in recent forest fires, Israeli firefighting infrastructure approaches Third World standards and would be woefully ineffective.4. Iranian mullahs are not suicidal. Even if they had a few baby bombs they would be in no hurry to launch them. They all want to live to pray another day for the death of Israel.3. Within 20 minutes of an attack, Iran is expected to shut down the very narrow Strait of Hormuz. Almost a third of the world’s oil flows through this strait. Gasoline in the US would jump to $10 a gallon overnight. The expected six-month closing of this chokepoint would devastate the global economy.2. Much of the supplies for American troops in Iraq and Afghanistan flow through this strait. America will not have time to procure alternate routes.1. And as to whether it’s “good for the Jews,” no way! Jews all over the world would be blamed for the consequences of this action even if it succeeded and made Israel “safer.”STEVEN SMOLINNew York
November 17: Choosing justices...
The Knesset is our supreme political body due to simple fact: We have no framed and sealed constitution that would be above its current primacy.
GERSHON HARRIS Hatzor HaglilitDefining a columnSir, – Although I may not agree with him, I have considered Shmuley Boteach a careful writer.So his personal comment while discussing the late co-founder of Apple (“Lessons from the brutal truth about Steve Jobs,” Comment & Features, November 15) about being “orders of magnitude less successful than he (as indeed I am)...” surprised me.What could possibly be Boteach’s definition of success? He may well have meant less financially successful, but he didn’t say that. Freudian slip maybe, but nurturing relationships and striving to leave behind a good name define success in life.Each of us can strive in some way to fulfill the purpose we have been uniquely assigned. We can dedicate our energies toward attaining these goals. But measuring one’s success against that of another on the money scale is delusive and defeating.PESACH GOODLEY Telz StoneSir, – The topic of his column is Steve Jobs, but at the end, Shmuley Boteach segues into what has become a favorite for him of late – US politics. Which begs the question: What qualifies him to be an expert on US politics? Boteach was presumably given his column based on his unique niche as an Orthodox rabbi willing to talk candidly about sex, and on the knowledge and experience he has in that area. Yet he engages in the time-honored but questionable custom practiced by many a rabbi, that of using his bully pulpit to give weight to political views about which he is no more knowledgeable than any layperson.In this column, Boteach argues that Jimmy Carter – intelligent but ineffectual – proves that being smart doesn’t necessarily lead to being a good president.This might be true. But having worked at Oxford, the rabbi surely knows it doesn’t prove the inverse, that lack of intelligence is an asset for a potential president.On the contrary, common sense dictates that, all other things being equal, we want the leader of the most powerful nation to be well-versed in the complex issues affecting the US and the world.Boteach’s belief that for GOP hopeful Rick Perry, surrounding himself with “really bright people” is a perfectly good substitute for intelligence, is a case of deja-vu: The exact same argument was made for then-candidate George W. Bush, another Texas governor with a lackluster grasp of national issues. (And we all know how that presidency worked out.) Using Boteach’s own rabbinic advice – that we refrain from overly blunt and hurtful remarks – I encourage him to continue writing about those issues on which he is an expert!ERIC SOMMER OranitOne man’s Top 10Sir, – Regarding “EU ministers divided over strike on Iran” (November 15), the following are the top 10 reasons why bombing that country is moronic at best: 10. The Israeli intelligence services are dead-set against the idea.9. Experts in field believe that, if successful, it would delay the program by only two years.8. Intelligence estimates say 100,000 missiles are now on line, including many with advanced systems and enhanced range and accuracy, not only in Iran but also in Gaza, Lebanon and Syria.7. Israel can expect a missile barrage on its major cities for 40 days and 40 nights.6. Israeli commanders have woefully underestimated enemy resolve and capability over the past five years.5. As proven in recent forest fires, Israeli firefighting infrastructure approaches Third World standards and would be woefully ineffective.4. Iranian mullahs are not suicidal. Even if they had a few baby bombs they would be in no hurry to launch them. They all want to live to pray another day for the death of Israel.3. Within 20 minutes of an attack, Iran is expected to shut down the very narrow Strait of Hormuz. Almost a third of the world’s oil flows through this strait. Gasoline in the US would jump to $10 a gallon overnight. The expected six-month closing of this chokepoint would devastate the global economy.2. Much of the supplies for American troops in Iraq and Afghanistan flow through this strait. America will not have time to procure alternate routes.1. And as to whether it’s “good for the Jews,” no way! Jews all over the world would be blamed for the consequences of this action even if it succeeded and made Israel “safer.”STEVEN SMOLINNew York