Politics dividing US Orthodox synagogue movement

The Young Israel synagogue in Scarsdale, New York (photo credit: YISNY)
The Young Israel synagogue in Scarsdale, New York
(photo credit: YISNY)
At the end of March, the National Council of Young Israel, an Orthodox synagogue association, will hold a gala dinner hosted by Pete Hegseth, the co-host of Fox & Friends.
The invitation advertises that Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) and former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee will speak. Tommy Hicks, the co-chairman of the Republican National Committee, will receive the Guardian of Israel award. The chairman of the dinner, Rabbi Yechezkel Moskowitz, has tweeted that “#DemocratsAreDestroyingAmerica.”
Moskowitz has also trained his Twitter fire on Young Israel rabbis who object to their group’s right-wing tilt.
“Everyone of the Rabbis on this list from reconstructionist lover @RabbiStarrYITH to tree hugger Barry Kornblau should be ashamed of themselves joining with liberal progressive groups like @IfNotNowOrg in attacking @NCYIYoungIsrael for defending Israel’s democracy,” he tweeted on Monday.
Moskowitz told JTA that he speaks only for himself, not Young Israel.
In non-Twitter-speak, Moskowitz was referring to a small-scale rebellion in the 107-year-old association, which counts more than 100 Orthodox synagogues nationwide among its members. Young Israel synagogues practice Orthodox Judaism and are Zionist. The name Young Israel is one of the most identifiable markers of an Orthodox synagogue in the United States.
For years, the National Council of Young Israel has issued public statements largely supporting right-wing policies and politicians, including those of President Donald Trump. But now a group of Young Israel rabbis and leaders are protesting the group’s political positions. They say that such statements do not necessarily represent their views and are made without consulting member synagogues. Some synagogues have floated leaving Young Israel over this issue.
“I would have liked an apology for speaking on our behalf, with divisive issues that are not representative,” said Rabbi Adam Starr, who leads Young Israel of Toco Hills in Atlanta, Georgia. Starr was one of the rabbis whom Moskowitz called out in his tweet.
“There certainly have been statements made in the past on political issues,” Starr said. “My approach is not about whether it’s right-wing or left-wing. A synagogue organization should not be making deeply divisive political statements on our behalf.”
All major American Jewish religious movements weigh in on public policy, usually with a distinct ideological if not partisan tilt. And the National Council of Young Israel’s president, Farley Weiss, told JTA that he sees such advocacy as part of the group’s mission.
Weiss said that the Jewish people face “existential threats,” pointing in particular to statements by Representative Ilhan Omar (D-MN) that many see echo antisemitic stereotypes. He added that Young Israel has long been politically active, working on behalf of displaced Holocaust survivors, Soviet Jewry and various pro-Israel causes, like moving the US Embassy to Jerusalem.
“I know that the overwhelming majority of our shuls want us speak out on these issues,” he said. “The National Council of Young Israel has been, historically, an organization of activism that has been unparalleled in Jewish organizations.”
THE CURRENT BACKLASH came over politics in Israel, not in America. Last week, Weiss defended Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu brokering a deal with Otzma Yehudit or Jewish Home, a far Right political party, for a merger with the more moderate right-wing Bayit Yehudi or Jewish Home Party ahead of elections in April. A range of American Jewish groups condemned the move as a normalization of bigotry. Weiss called it a matter of political calculus.
Weiss said that the statement was meant to defend a legitimate political maneuver — “what we consider to be a decision made that was not going to lead to anything more than the Jewish Home Party being part of the government coalition.”
After Starr and other Young Israel congregational rabbis objected, Weiss clarified in a statement that he was speaking for himself and a majority of the board, not necessarily for member synagogues. But the controversy has not abated. Last week, 23 Young Israel synagogues signed a statement objecting to Weiss’s comment in particular as well as to Young Israel’s political statements.
“In recognition of the current, highly divisive political environment in the United States, Israel, and beyond, we… call upon NCYI leadership to immediately cease making all political pronouncements,” the synagogues’ statement said.
Weiss is unhappy that synagogues chose to make a public statement objecting to his stance, especially after he clarified that he was not speaking for them. He said it was the first time that a statement of his elicited this level of backlash.
“To me that should have been the end of it, and if they wanted to say things to their congregations or under their own names, it’s perfectly fine to do that,” he said. “I don’t think they should have made a statement and made a public debate.”
But some Young Israel rabbis say there is a larger issue at play here.
Rabbi Barry Kornblau of the Young Israel of Hollis Hills-Windsor Park in Queens, New York, called the Jewish Power statement “the final hammer blow, the straw that broke the camel’s back.”
“There’s been long-simmering discontent among numerous Young Israel congregations, Young Israel leaders, Young Israel rabbis, regarding a whole variety of public policy statements that have been issued by the leadership of NCYI,” said Kornblau, one of the public statement’s co-authors and another target of Moskowitz’s Twitter fire. “Local rabbis and lay leaders do not want to be addressing such controversies in their communities.”
SOME SAY that the issue spans beyond the Israeli election statement. Recent years have seen national Young Israel leadership unabashedly supporting Republican politics in a variety of forums.
Young Israel’s first vice president, Joseph Frager, effusively praised Trump at a February event in Israel. A Young Israel staff member gave a benediction at the recent Conservative Political Action Conference. Following the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting in October, Young Israel thanked Trump for visiting Pittsburgh and posted on Facebook, “The Jewish people in the US & Israel have never had such a great champion in the White House.”
In addition, US Ambassador to Israel David Friedman belonged to a Young Israel near his home in Woodmere, New York. Friedman was Trump’s attorney.
“Truthfully, you have never seen anything – the revolution that this man has created for the Jewish community in the world, and particularly in Israel,” said Frager, referring to Trump. “Incredible things that people just take for granted, but we don’t take for granted… I know everyone in the National Council of Young Israel doesn’t take for granted. We know who our friends are and what they have done.”
And Weiss’s Jewish Power statement is not the first controversial one that Young Israel has made. Last year it defended Representative Louie Gohmert (R-TX) after he suggested that liberal financier George Soros betrayed fellow Jews during the Holocaust. Soros survived the Holocaust as a young teen by hiding in the family home of a gentile who occasionally took him along when he surveyed Jewish-owned properties.
In 2016, studies showed that most Orthodox Jews voted for Trump, even as most Jews voted for Hillary Clinton. For American Jews who favor hawkish positions on Israel, supporting Trump has come naturally since he has forged a close alliance with Netanyahu.
Weiss said there is no problem with praising Trump for what he sees as two groundbreaking pro-Israel actions: moving the embassy to Jerusalem and withdrawing from the Iranian nuclear deal brokered by Obama.
“People view our praise of him, on especially these two issues, as somehow we’re being more partisan,” he said. “The fact is, when I was [Young Israel] president under President Obama, when I felt there was something we could praise President Obama for, we praised him.”
The protesting rabbis say they have two problems with the council’s statements: how contentious their subject matter can be, and that synagogues are not consulted before the statements are released. Rabbi Hershel Billet of Young Israel of Woodmere, New York, says that synagogues should at the very least have a chance to read and respond to statements before they go out.
“It means they’re speaking in the name of my synagogue,” said Billet, a former president of the Rabbinical Council of America. “How are they supposed to know when they’re speaking in the name of my synagogue or not? President Trump has certainly done good things for Israel. Nevertheless, that is a political statement. If you’re going to make a statement, you have to be speaking for the entire Young Israel National Council.”
Weiss believes the statements do reflect Young Israel’s synagogues because delegates from member congregations elect the slate of national board members. He said that he composes the political statements in conjunction with Frager and a public relations consultant.
WILL THE PROTESTING synagogues leave Young Israel? As of now, none have any immediate plans to do so, though a couple of rabbis discussed the idea.
Discontent among those synagogues has only risen as the dinner approaches. And tweets by Moskowitz attacking the protesting rabbis have inflamed tensions even more.
“Unfortunately ‘some’ Rabbis, such as yourself, have decided to become tools of the liberal Progressive Left in a crusade to push their ideology,” Moskowitz tweeted to Starr on Tuesday. “Baruch Hashem, lines are going to be drawn in the sand and I think that this is just the beginning.”
Starr responded to Moskowitz’s initial Twitter attack on Facebook, where he wrote, “Yes, I am a Reconstructionist lover, and a Reform lover and a conservative lover and an Orthodox lover, because I love all Jews. Even those who make mistakes in judgment such as tweeting something like this.”
Since then, Weiss has asked Moskowitz to refrain from attacking Young Israel rabbis personally, and chalked up the statements to the polarizing effect of social media. He added that Young Israel aims to commend pro-Israel Democrats as well as Republicans. In addition to the Republicans, Grace Meng (D-NY) will also speak at the dinner.
Moskowitz also told JTA that he believes Young Israel should strive to be bipartisan. But he still had harsh words for the Democratic Party.
“I am 100% committed to this dinner, to make sure Young Israel is a success in a bipartisan fashion, to represent its bipartisan values,” he said, adding later that “I have very good relations with Democrats. When I say Democrats are destroying America, it’s not directed at a person. It’s as a movement. I believe their agenda will destroy America.”
Before the Twitter war, Starr told JTA that his synagogue board was considering dropping the Young Israel affiliation. He’s not sure what benefit it brings to the congregation, which is also affiliated with the Orthodox Union, a centrist Orthodox umbrella group.
“Many Young Israels, including my [own], are also OU synagogues,” Starr said. “So we’re a proud member of the Orthodox Union. What is the value of having multiple synagogue affiliations?”
Billet said, “I have no great need to be the rabbi of a Young Israel synagogue,” but that “there’s been no major uprising in my community to say that we don’t want to be members.”
For his part, Moskowitz tweeted that Starr’s synagogue should leave the movement. It took part in a joint memorial service with a Reconstructionist congregation following the Pittsburgh shooting. He said “that alone should have it booted from the national council.”
But other Young Israel congregations that signed the protest statement still want to remain part of the movement. Rabbi Moshe Shulman of Young Israel of St. Louis, Missouri said that being a Young Israel member means having recognition – and taking part in a national movement.
“If they want to move to the community or are passing through, they hear Young Israel, they know that’s an Orthodox shul,” he said. “There are other Young Israels around the country we connect with. There’s a lot of value to being a synagogue that has a name that represents something.”