Knesset Speaker Reuven Rivlin slammed the new version of the NGO bill on Thursday, saying that it is an indication of politicians “going crazy.”
RELATED:Begin declares NGO bills ‘practically dead’ Bill limiting NGO power at High Court rejected
The new bill, a combination of proposals by by MK Ofir Akunis (Likud) and MK Faina Kirschenbaum (Israel Beiteinu), limits foreign government donations to NGOs by dividing them into three categories with different standards for taxation and capping contributions.
Likud sources said on Wednesday night that the bill resulted from a compromise between Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman; however, the Prime Minister’s Office has yet to make a public statement on the matter.
Minister without Portfolio Bennie Begin was skeptical that Netanyahu actually agreed to the new version, as the prime minister’s advisers told him that on Thursday afternoon that Netanyahu has yet to read the bill.
“We need to be careful [discussing the NGO bill],” he said. “All of this is adding noise to the system, and is causing us harm on the international stage.”
“The public is already over-saturated and tired from these initiatives,”
Rivlin said. “It seems like there are some MKs that do not rest for a
minute and want to bring chaos, because of immediate political needs.”
“Whoever wants to go crazy, can go crazy,” he quipped.
The Knesset Speaker said that, in his opinion, the new proposal is just as inappropriate as the previous one.
“This doesn’t solve any problems. It makes them worse by forming a
political committee in the Knesset to regulate opinions and ideas,” he
Rivlin said that the bill is a “bad idea, because a state that creates political commissars is not a true democracy.”
According to the new version of the bill, organizations that reject
Israel’s right to exist, call for boycotts of the state or tell IDF
soldiers to refuse orders, among other actions, may not receive any
funding from foreign governments. Political NGOs will have to pay a 45%
tax on such donations, unless the Knesset Finance Committee decides to
waive the tax following a hearing. Non-political organizations that
receive state funding will be tax-exempt and may receive unlimited
donations from foreign governments.
Akunis and Kirschenbaum explain in the bill’s text that “many
organizations in Israel set a goal for themselves to condemn the State
of Israel before the world and persecute IDF soldiers and officers by
sullying their good name.”
“These organizations, which often call themselves ‘human rights
organizations,’ are funded by states and anonymous sources that seek to
harm and change the political public discourse in Israel,” they added.
The two pointed out Israel NGOs’ cooperation with the Goldstone Report
as an example of a way in which they use foreign government
contributions to harm Israel.
Defense Minister Ehud Barak’s Independence Party took a more cautious
stance on the bill, with faction chairman Einat Wilf saying that “the
values the new NGO bill seeks to promote are acceptable and important.
“However, we must ensure that they are implemented equally in every NGO,
whether on the right or left.”
“The bill must be fixed so that it forbids any foreign element – private
or governmental - from supporting an Israeli NGO that encourages
evading IDF service or subverting the State of Israel’s character as a
Jewish and democratic state or inciting to racism,” she added.
Wilf also said that the Independence faction opposes bringing NGOs to a
hearing before the Knesset Finance Committee, calling the idea
Opposition MKs slammed the bill, saying that the new version is not significantly different from its predecessor.
“This isn’t a real change, it’s cosmetic,” MK Yoel Hasson (Kadima) said.
“This is just an attempt to make it seem more moderate, following
The Kadima MK called the legislation “part of a group of bills that are
meant to limit freedom of expression and organization. The government is
attacking anyone that opposes it.”
MK Nachman Shai, also of Kadima, said “the new NGO bill is cutting off
Israeli democracy’s wings. These limitations will harm the independence
and freedom of action of Israeli civil society.”
“There is no democracy without a live, active civil society,” he warned.
“This is the same ugly wolf in a different sheep’s clothing,” Labor
faction chairman Eitan Cabel said. “When someone walks like a fascist
and talks like a fascist, he’s a fascist, even if he wears a democratic
Cabel called for Netanyahu to “bang on the table and stop this political bullying, without compromises.”
“That is what a real leader would do,” he added, “but Netanyahu is a
prime minister that is ruled by the right-wing margins of the crazy
coalition he formed.”
Meretz MKs also slammed the bill, with MK Zehava Gal-On stating that “the witch hunt continues.”
“The new version is even worse than the original, because it accuses and
punishes organizations that criticize the government without a trial,”
she explained. “I call for the prime minister to put this bill in the
freezer and stop embarrassing the State of Israel with his party’s
bizarre legislation, which is inspired by Lieberman.”
“The Bibi-Liberman coalition continues to trample and destroy democracy
in Israel,” MK Nitzan Horowitz (Meretz) said. “The ‘new’ NGO bill is
still trying to dry out civil organizations.”