'Most African migrants treated at clinic suffered abuse'

PHR-Israel: Most who report for treatment in Jaffa report being locked up against their will or suffering physical abuse during their journey to Israel.

February 24, 2011 04:25
4 minute read.
A Sudanese refugee at the border fence between Isr

sudanese at fence 311. (photo credit: Channel 10)


Dear Reader,
As you can imagine, more people are reading The Jerusalem Post than ever before. Nevertheless, traditional business models are no longer sustainable and high-quality publications, like ours, are being forced to look for new ways to keep going. Unlike many other news organizations, we have not put up a paywall. We want to keep our journalism open and accessible and be able to keep providing you with news and analyses from the frontlines of Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World.

As one of our loyal readers, we ask you to be our partner.

For $5 a month you will receive access to the following:

  • A user experience almost completely free of ads
  • Access to our Premium Section
  • Content from the award-winning Jerusalem Report and our monthly magazine to learn Hebrew - Ivrit
  • A brand new ePaper featuring the daily newspaper as it appears in print in Israel

Help us grow and continue telling Israel’s story to the world.

Thank you,

Ronit Hasin-Hochman, CEO, Jerusalem Post Group
Yaakov Katz, Editor-in-Chief

UPGRADE YOUR JPOST EXPERIENCE FOR 5$ PER MONTH Show me later Don't show it again

The majority of African migrants who report for treatment at a clinic in Jaffa operated by Physicians for Human Rights-Israel report being locked up against their will or suffering physical abuse during their journey here, the organization reported on Wednesday.

According to PHR-Israel, 59 percent of migrants treated at the organization’s Open Clinic in Jaffa said they had been held in physical restraints, 52% said they were subjected to physical abuse, and 44% reportedly witnessed violence and fatalities suffered by other migrants en route to Israel.

Be the first to know - Join our Facebook page.

PHR-Israel said that migrants, most of them from Eritrea, are being held hostage by smugglers at “torture camps” in the El-Arish area of the Sinai Peninsula, while trying to make their way to Israel.

The smugglers reportedly hold them in such conditions until they can obtain thousands of dollars in ransom from their families.

According to PHR-Israel, the smugglers telephone relatives of the migrants and have them listen in while they use systematic violence against their loved ones in order to extort ransom from them.

“Survivors report the use of systemic violence, including punching, slapping, kicking and whipping. Forms of torture include burial in sand, electric shocks, hanging by the hands and legs, branding with hot metal, as well as rape and sexual abuse,” PHR-Israel said.

Beginning about a year ago, PHR-Israel’s staff “began to notice an increase in the number of female asylum-seekers coming to the clinic to request abortions. Open Clinic staff soon found out that many of the women were repeatedly raped in Sinai while on their way to Israel.”

As a result, the organization created a questionnaire that has been given to new patients in order to paint a picture of what they say they went through in Sinai.

From October 12, 2010, to January 30, 2011, PHR-Israel questioned 284 migrants, from which, in addition to physical imprisonment, “52% of the respondents reported that they were subjected to serious violence.

Approximately 15% have scars and signs of violence on their bodies from the torture they suffered in Sinai.

“In addition, 44% of respondents stated that they witnessed violence and/or fatalities of other asylum-seekers while they were in Sinai; 88% stated that they experienced severe hunger and food deprivation; and 66% reported that they were denied access to water.”

As a result of the findings, PHR-Israel has called on the Health Ministry to grant migrants coverage under the National Health Insurance Law, regardless of their status in Israel.

PHR-Israel on Wednesday cited a recent report by the Italian NGO Agenzia Habeshia, which said that around 190 migrants from Eritrea and Ethiopian were being held at two “torture camps” in Sinai, and that smugglers were demanding ransoms of up $10,000 for each captive. This is in addition to the thousands of dollars in smuggling fees the migrants already pay to the smugglers before setting out for Israel.

In the wake of such revelations, PHR-Israel called on the international community “to act in cooperation with the relevant authorities in Egypt in order to locate and free refugees and asylum-seekers who are still being held captive for ransom, to ensure that, after their release, these individuals receive comprehensive attention and protection, including safe passage to a third country.”

They also ask for the international community to launch a dialogue with the Egyptian armed forces in order to put an end to their shooting of migrants trying to cross into Israel from Sinai.

The PHR-Israel announcement comes a week after the Hotline for Migrant Workers released a report titled “The Dead of the Wilderness” describing the ordeals reportedly suffered by African migrants to Israel at the hands of their Beduin smugglers in Sinai.

The report is full of descriptions of rape, torture, murder, extortion and near-starvation that emerged from interviews the hotline conducted with 60 African migrants mainly from Eritrea. The 24 women and 36 men reported suffering severe brutality on their way to Israel.

When asked why the two reports had come out in such quick succession, PHR-Israel executive director Ran Cohen said the group’s report was more of a followup to a report it put out in December titled “Hostages, Torture, and Rape in the Sinai Desert.” It stated that “out of 165 abortions facilitated by the clinic between January and November 2010, PHR-Israel suspects that half were request by women who were sexually assaulted in Sinai.”

Cohen said that in contrast to the Hotline report, “ours more looks at the breadth of the phenomenon, which is very extensive.” He added that “after the revolution in Egypt, we feel that it is very important to bring this subject to the daily agenda of Israel and the international community so that steps will be taken to fight it.

“After what happened in Egypt, it’s become even more difficult to get there to deal with the issue, because right now there is no stable government to speak of.”

When asked what his organization wants from the state, Cohen said: “Up to today, the State of Israel hasn’t taken any steps to help or treat these victims. We must seek a quick, meaningful solution and give them social residency, acknowledging they have social rights in Israel without deciding if they are refugees or not.”

Cohen said PHR-Israel wasn’t asking for the Interior Ministry to give the migrants refugee status – rather, for the time being, “to give them immediate health and welfare service without any connection to whether or not they should be given refugee status.

“They’re here, and they are victims of terrible circumstances, and we must help them immediately,” he said.

Related Content

August 31, 2014
Rioting resumes throughout east Jerusalem Saturday night