Eritrean migrants in Sinai 311 (R).
(photo credit: Asmaa Waguih / Reuters)
formulating a new law Wednesday stipulating legal treatment of migrant
workers and infiltrators found crossing the Israeli border illegally,
after an already drafted
bill was pulled in July 2010 due to harsh public criticism. The new law
would allow the
government to remand migrants crossing the border at a non-regulated
point for up to three years.
Drafters of the bill
seek to replace the 1954 Entry into Israel law, and raise the potential
consequences asylum seekers may face if they choose to infiltrate
Israel's borders illegally, including detention time, the ability to
stand before a judge, and periodic inspections of the remanded by the
authorities. The announcement of the new bill comes two days before a Knesset recess without public hearings.
PM sets summer 2012 as completion date for Egypt fence
MK calls on gov't to deal with 'infiltrators' from Sinai
Netanyahu: ''Infiltrators' are conquering Tel Aviv'
As opposed to the old bill, the new law does not depend on there being a state of emergency to implement its various conditions.
According to the new bill, asylum seekers and their children who cross
over illegally into Israel could be arrested for a period of three
years, and not 60 days as the present law stipulates, Army Radio reported.
The new bill also extends the detention time period after which the
asylum seeker can appear before a judge from 96 hours to 14 days, and
periodic inspection of the remanded will be conducted not once a month
according to the Israel Entry law, but rather once every two months.
Migrants found crossing into Israel whose place of origin poses a
security threat, such as the Darfur region in Sudan, face more serious
detention as well. The new bill stipulates that the asylum seeker, as
well as his or her children, can be held in detention without release
even under extenuating humanitarian circumstances, and even if the
migrant himself was never involved in security operations.
the bill is passed, it could be possible to imprison asylum seekers for
up to five years, and those who aid in the migrant's "infiltration" or
provide him or her shelter for up to 15 years.
groups Association for Civil Rights and the Hotline for Migrant Workers
decried the bill, calling it "draconian," and claiming the bill
"eliminates Israel's obligations towards refugees and asylum seekers."
The groups added that a "democracy does not offer such a bill, and
certainly not...right before a Knesset recess."