We independently evaluate all recommended products and services.
If you click on the links we provide, we may receive compensation.

The Best Murder Mystery Games for 2024

Turn your next social gathering into a thrilling adventure with our selection of the best murder mystery board games.

 10 Best Murder Mystery Games for 2023 (photo credit: PR)
10 Best Murder Mystery Games for 2023
(photo credit: PR)

Our Top Picks

Jump to Review
Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Body on the Boardwalk
Jump to Review
Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Jamie Banks
Jump to Review
Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Death at the Dive Bar
Jump to Review
Cryptic Killers Murder Mystery Game: Murder of a Millionaire
Jump to Review
Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Falcone Veronica

If you're in search of an engaging and unique pastime to engage your friends and family, we highly recommend considering a murder mystery game for your next social gathering. These not only stimulate your critical thinking and detective powers but also ensure an evening brimming with entertainment and suspense. Whether you're inclined towards classic case files, spine-chilling haunted houses, or offbeat mysteries, there is a game tailored to every taste. There are a few things to consider when selecting which game to go for, such as your group size, the game's complexity, and your preferred theme. We've sorted through the reviews and come up with a list of some of the most enjoyable murder mystery games people are playing. Check out what we've found and spice up your next party or event!

1

Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Body on the Boardwalk

Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Body on the Boardwalk
Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Body on the Boardwalk

Hunt A Killer Body on the Boardwalk is a thrilling and immersive murder mystery game that will keep players on the edge of their seats. This game is designed for ages 14+ and is perfect for independent challenges, date nights, or with family and friends as detectives. The game includes all the necessary materials for players to solve the unsolved case and bring the killer to justice. With intricate clues, hidden secrets, and unexpected twists, this murder mystery game will provide hours of entertainment for mystery lovers.

Rated 9.9 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Immersive murder mystery game, Great for date night or family/friends, Challenging and engaging gameplay
Cons
Not suitable for children under 14

2

Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Jamie Banks

Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Jamie Banks
Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Jamie Banks

Unsolved Case Files: Jamie Banks is a thrilling and immersive murder mystery game that challenges players to solve a cold case murder mystery. The game comes with everything needed to play, including crime scene photographs, witness statements, and evidence. With attention to detail and careful analysis, players can piece together the clues and solve the case. This murder mystery game is well-designed, and the clues are well-crafted, making for an engaging and satisfying experience.

Rated 9.6 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Engaging murder mystery game, Realistic case file materials, Online answer keys
Cons
May be too confusing for some

3

Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Death at the Dive Bar

Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Death at the Dive Bar
Hunt a Killer Murder Mystery Game: Death at the Dive Bar

Hunt A Killer's Death at the Dive Bar is an immersive murder mystery game that allows players to take on an unsolved case as an independent challenge or with family and friends as detectives for the night. Designed for ages 14 and up, this game is perfect for those who love solving puzzles, uncovering clues, and piecing together a thrilling story. With its high-quality materials and intricate details, this murder mystery game will keep you engaged and entertained for hours.

Rated 9.4 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Immersive murder mystery game, Can be played with family/friends, Challenging and engaging gameplay
Cons
May be too challenging for younger players

4

Cryptic Killers Murder Mystery Game: Murder of a Millionaire

Cryptic Killers Murder Mystery Game: Murder of a Millionaire
Cryptic Killers Murder Mystery Game: Murder of a Millionaire

mystery game immerses you in a world of detective work, complete with clues and evidence to unravel the mystery behind a millionaire's murder. It's perfect for solo play, a unique date night, or as the centerpiece of a party group. Setting up and playing the game is a breeze, offering endless hours of engaging fun and mystery. Crafted with durable, high-quality materials, this murder mystery game is designed to be enjoyed repeatedly, making it a great addition to any game night collection.

Rated 9.3 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Physical and online evidence, Suitable for solo play and groups, High-quality design
Cons
Could be more structured

5

Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Falcone Veronica

Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Falcone Veronica
Unsolved Case Files Murder Mystery Game: Falcone Veronica

The Unsolved Case Files: Falcone, Veronica murder mystery game is an absolute must for puzzle and mystery enthusiasts. In this game, you're the detective charged with cracking a cold case murder. It's all about sharpening your analytical skills and focusing on the details as you sift through clues, question suspects, and strive to solve the crime. Whether you're planning a captivating evening with friends or itching for a solo challenge to test your problem-solving prowess, this murder mystery game is an ideal pick. It's thoughtfully crafted with top-notch materials and captivating gameplay that promises to keep you engaged from beginning to end.

Rated 9 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Engaging murder mystery game, Real evidence to analyze, Challenging and interactive gameplay
Cons
Cursive text can be difficult to read

6

Cryptic Killers Murder Mystery Game: Merivale Manor

Cryptic Killers Murder Mystery Game: Merivale Manor
Cryptic Killers Murder Mystery Game: Merivale Manor

Cryptic Killers Unsolved: Murder at Merivale Manor is an engaging and thrilling murder mystery game that will have you and your friends trying to solve a cold-case murder mystery. With detailed evidence and crime files, you'll feel like a real detective as you try to piece together clues and solve the case. Perfect for individuals, date nights, or party games, this murder mystery game will keep everyone entertained and on the edge of their seats.

Rated 8.9 based on 10
JPOST
Pros
Realistic physical evidence, Suitable for individuals and parties, Provides detective-like experience
Cons
May be too easy for experienced players

FAQ

Q: What is a murder mystery game?

A: In a murder mystery game, a party-style activity, guests step into the shoes of characters from a fictional murder investigation narrative. Together, they collaborate to decipher clues, collect evidence, and eventually pinpoint the culprit behind the murder.

Q: How many players are needed for a murder mystery game?

A: Murder mystery games are flexible in terms of player numbers, but ideally, they are played with a group of 6 to 8 participants. Nevertheless, there are versions of these games that can cater to larger gatherings, accommodating 20 or more players.

Q: Can I host a murder mystery game remotely?

A: Yes, many murder mystery games can be hosted remotely through video conferencing platforms. Some games are specifically designed for remote play, while others can be adapted for virtual play with a little creativity and planning.

Conclusions

From the intriguing Murder Mystery Party Case Files to the captivating Hunt a Killer series, these immersive games are ideal for date nights, family game nights, and even independent challenges. These murder mystery games go beyond simple fun and offer players a unique and memorable trial. I strongly recommend exploring these murder mystery games to infuse your game night with a dose of suspenseful fun. Each game brings a unique twist, ensuring a dynamic and engaging experience that enhances the thrill of the gaming atmosphere. Embrace the mystery and add a new dimension to your game nights!