Israel cannot win the battle for its legitimacy by constantly responding to its critics. It must take control of the narrative, mobilize international allies and make the case for Zionism on its own terms, panelists at The Jerusalem Post Summit in Australia have stressed.

Former MK Dr. Einat Wilf and Ayal Marek, President, ARZA Australia, argued that confronting the growing acceptance of anti-Zionism requires both greater preparedness within Jewish communities and a coordinated international effort to challenge that.

According to Wilf, Jews must prepare for increasingly extreme possibilities while recognizing the importance of building alliances with people willing to push back against anti-Zionism.

“Jews historically suffer from a timing problem,” she said, warning that by the time the wider world recognizes the dangers of an extremist ideology, Jews have often already borne the consequences.

She called on Jewish communities to take responsibility for their own security while identifying allies who understand the historical consequences of institutionalized anti-Zionism.

“Everywhere anti-Zionism rose to become an institutionalized ideology, Jews disappeared. Put aside your personal emotions, thoughts, and views. This is a fact. Everywhere anti-Zionism became institutionalized, from the Arab world to Iran to the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, Jews were gone. If you understand that this is a fact, does it not horrify you?”

“My message is that this is the time to take care of our own, in whatever way you see fit,” she said.

Wilf argued that non-Jews must recognize anti-Zionism as an ideology that damages the societies in which it takes hold, adding that they should be equipped with the tools to challenge it.

“Once we identify our allies, we need to give them the tools to fight back because, ultimately, we don't have the numbers,” Wilf said, adding that those are “the two parallel approaches: prepare for the worst within our community and reach out to allies who can help push back.

Addressing how to make Zionism compelling to younger generations, Wilf described it as an ideology rooted in responsibility, creativity and building.

“Zionism is the ideology and attitude of people who build…It is the mindset of people who, in the face of trauma and difficulty, create, innovate, and build.  Zionism is the attitude of people who look at life's adversity and say, "I'll deal with it. I'll assume responsibility. I'll make something of it” she said, contrasting it with what she described as anti-Zionism's culture of blame and victimhood.

Define the narrative

According to Marek, Israel needs to shift from a defensive posture to actively defining its own story.

“At the moment, we're playing defense. We're operating on a field defined by others. The narrative has been set by others,” he said. “We need to move from defending to defining, from being reactive to setting the narrative ourselves.”

He called for credible local voices rather than paid influencers, faster responses to misinformation and messages tailored to different audiences. He also stressed the need for greater strategic coordination among the many organizations and individuals working to defend Israel's legitimacy as well as the need to focus on the right audience with the right messages.

“We need trusted voices within communities, people who share the values of those communities and understand the issues. Not paid influencers, because that often backfires once it's exposed. We need genuine people whose voices carry credibility,” he said, adding that “we also need to act quickly. Governments, for understandable reasons, can take time to formulate responses. We need to respond immediately before a false narrative becomes embedded in people's minds.

Marek added that Israel should define Zionism on its own terms: the Jewish people's right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. He also urged Israel to tell a broader story, highlighting its achievements in science, technology, innovation and international development.

“There is so much that can be shown to the world, and we need to find better ways to share that story,” he said.