A rare vision of interfaith harmony

The funeral of former Jewish community leader Carmen Weinstein provides new focus on Egypt’s Jews.

Carmen Weinstein 370 (photo credit: courtesy)
Carmen Weinstein 370
(photo credit: courtesy)
Against the backdrop of accusations of religious intolerance being leveled at the Morsi government, the scene in Cairo on April 18 as Muslims participated in the funeral of former Jewish community leader Carmen Weinstein was both incongruous and encouraging. To some, it was an example of growing Egyptian Muslim interest in the dwindling Jewish population, especially since the Egyptian Revolution in 2011.
“This is the first time I have seen this number of visitors and journalists come to the synagogue,” marveled Magda Haroun, Weinstein’s successor at the Cairo Jewish Community Center. “I am glad they’re all here, and I would love to see them more often,” she said.
Indeed, with some 100 Muslims in attendance at the funeral along with about “two handfuls” of Jews, the impression of harmony, brotherhood, love and support for each other was also reflected in the eulogies for Weinstein.
Even Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi issued a statement mourning the loss of Weinstein, saying, “She was a dedicated Egyptian who worked tirelessly to preserve the Egyptian Jewish heritage and valued, above all, living and dying in her country, Egypt.”
Kaddish was recited by Moroccan rabbi Mark Elfassy, who came from Paris to officiate and help provide the needed quorum of 10 Jewish men.
“We needed 10 Jewish males to attend the service, and I guess God has granted us what we needed. I don’t care if the males present were Muslims or Jews, as long as they loved Carmen. You can’t really tell who is a Jew and who isn’t,” Elfassy said.
Such a gathering would have been unheard of under the rule of president Gamal Abdel Nasser and other Egyptian governments. But the recent release of an independent film called Jews of Egypt by director Amir Ramses depicting the modern history of Egypt’s Jews has sparked interest in the Jewish community and its fascinating past among the nation’s Muslims.
The film, now playing at several theaters – and whose release Ramses says was delayed due to what the government claimed were national security concerns – shows how discussions about Jewish heritage and Jews living in Egypt were silenced during Nasser’s rule (1950-72) and beyond, as well as how little the average Egyptian knows about their Jewish neighbors.
Critics who suggest the film reveals how much Egyptians don’t know about the history of their own country blame 60 years of misinformation from successive Egyptian governments and anti- Semites worldwide.
Ramses’s film underscores the patriotism the Jews displayed to Egypt despite their difficult situation. The movie, for instance, mentions the heroic and patriotic acts of such Egyptian Jews as political activist Henri Curiel during the Suez crisis of 1956, when he acquired secret information about the impending Anglo-French-Israeli invasion of Egypt, which he tried to pass on to Nasser. An attempt by Curiel to regain his Egyptian citizenship for this service, however, failed and the Sinai Campaign went ahead.
According to the movie, finally released after outcries from Egyptian liberal movements calling for free speech and media, Jews forced into leaving their own country never felt anything but Egyptian, and continued offering help to the Egyptian government, especially during Egyptian-Israeli wars.
ONE WHO nurtured his continued connection to his ancestors’ homeland was present at Weinstein’s funeral. Sam Amiel, an Egyptian Jew who now works in Israel as a senior program manager for the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee (JDC), attended as a way of connecting to the unforgotten lands of his father.
“I am an Egyptian Jew, the son of Moussa, who left for the United States some 50 years ago. I came back to be part of my heritage,” he said. He said, “We at JDC proudly send kosher food to Jewish people in Egypt.”
Many influential Egyptians attended the funeral at the Sha’ar Hashamayim Synagogue on Adly Street in downtown Cairo. Aly al-Saman, president of the International Union for Intercultural and Interfaith Dialogue and Peace Education for Europe and Egypt, told The Media Line that, “Egypt belongs to all faiths and it’s their [the Jews’] country as much as ours.”
Gaber el-Beltagy, a music professor and Egyptian opera star who sang at the centenary of the synagogue in 2007, and was also in attendance, said, “I sang a song at this place in seven languages to show the world that I am a Muslim, and I am happy to be among the Egyptian Jews, my partners in our country.”
Weinstein’s successor Haroun was also accompanied by Israel’s Ambassador to Egypt Ya’akov Amitai, who called Weinstein “a mother with a warm heart for the Egyptian Jewish community.”
After the rituals and speeches, Weinstein’s coffin was transferred for burial in the Jewish Cemetery of Basatin, the second oldest Jewish cemetery in the world. It was a fitting burial place for Weinstein, who worked diligently to restore the cemetery and to ensure it was included under the government restoration program for antiquities. The cemetery had been encroached on by trespassers and people living among the headstones.
“I hope that our efforts can stop the desecration of Basatin Cemetery,” Rabbi Andrew Baker of the Washington-based American Jewish Committee said at the funeral.
Filling Weinstein’s shoes won’t be easy, but Magda Haroun, also known as Maggy, is continuing the legacy of a modern, strong-willed Egyptian Jewish woman. Born in Alexandria 61 years ago, she practiced law at her father’s law firm and is currently a partner with her sister, Nadia Haroun.
The Haroun sisters, the youngest Jewish women in Egypt, were raised in a home where humanitarian values were sacred and love for Egypt intense.
“I am the daughter of Shehata Haroun, who didn’t know the difference between yellow, white or black. To him, Muslims, Jews and Christians were just human beings. We are Egyptians,” Maggy said proudly.
Shehata Haroun, who died in 2001, believed strongly in human and socialist values and refused to leave Egypt even when its Jews were coerced into doing so. He was a founding member of the Egyptian Communist Party along with leading Egyptian Muslim and Coptic politicians. However, he was better known for his hostility towards Zionism and Israel’s policies regarding the Palestinians.
While happy about the release of the film, Maggy Haroun is concerned over neglect and ignorance on the part of the Egyptian government and other Egyptians concerning those Jews who remain in Egypt, despite the fact that Egyptian Jews were an influential part of Egyptian society.
“Do people know that the architect who designed and built the famous Omar Makram Mosque was an Italian Jew living in Egypt, by the name of Maria Rossi? Do they know that the famous Egyptian movie star and singer Leila Mourad was a Jew?” she asks. Nonetheless, Maggy herself says, “I am an Egyptian before being Jewish.”
THAT EGYPTIAN part of their identity was always important to the Jews who settled there, having immigrated from elsewhere.
Egypt was a mecca for Jews around the world escaping persecution in the West, especially during the 15th and 16th centuries when Jews persecuted in Spain escaped to Egypt. A massive wave of Jewish merchants from throughout the Ottoman Empire also immigrated to Egypt when the Suez Canal was opened in 1869.
Not long ago, around the time of 1952 coup that ousted the last Egyptian monarch, King Farouk, Egypt had a vibrant, rich Jewish culture and Jews were prominent members of the Egyptian community. There were some 80,000 Egyptian Jews in 1952, but that number declined as Egyptian-Israeli relations worsened due to propaganda painting the Jews of the Arab world as conspirators and Zionists. After the Six Day War, massive numbers of Egyptians were forced to leave to escape prosecution for spying by state authorities.
Today, Egypt has 19 synagogues: 10 in Alexandria and nine in Cairo, but only three remain in operation: in Cairo, the Sha’ar Hashamayim Synagogue, the Maimonides Synagogue and the Ben-Ezra Synagogue in the Fustat area near the capital. The Eliyahu Hanavi Synagogue on Alexandria’s Nabi Daniel Street was closed for security reasons in 2012, after Egyptian officials there said they could not guarantee worshipers’ safety.
There are two types of Arabic-speaking Jews living in Egypt, believed to total fewer than 50, according to Haroun and her husband, but no official number is available. They are divided between the so-called “Rabbanite Jews” in Cairo, who also follow the oral law, and the Karaites in Alexandria, who follow only what is written in the Torah.
Maggy’s Italian Egyptian husband Dr. Roberto Orfanelli, who works at the Italian hospital in Cairo’s Abassia neighborhood, said, “We are all Egyptians, regardless of our religion. I am a Catholic and my wife is a Jew. I don’t like politics and I don’t believe in it. It’s a lot of headache. Most of the Jews in Egypt decided to stay away from politics and keep a low profile....
There was anti-Semitism in the United States as well, but here in Egypt it was worse.
“The remaining Egyptian Jews decided to stay below the radar in order to avoid friction due to the fact that Egyptians are unwillingly being fed misinformation about Egyptian Jews who were once a thread in the fabric of Egyptian society,” Orfanelli said. “Ramses’s film will hopefully help give Egyptians more real truths about the once illustrious Egyptian Jewish community.”
The turnout at the funeral gives Maggy Haroun hope about changing Muslim and Christian Egyptians’ views about the Jewish community as she tries to continue Weinstein’s legacy.
“I don’t feel threatened in my own country, and surprisingly, the Egyptian government, Muslim friends and the system are protecting me,” she said defiantly.
“It’s not fear that we experience here in Egypt. It’s ignorance – ignorance which calls into question our value as human beings and how much we want to live like everyone else, as Egyptians in peace!” she said, adding, “I will do my best to revive this Jewish heritage and restore our legacy as patriotic Egyptians.”