Christian missionaries “weaponize their relationship” with Israeli Jewish communities to spread Christianity, prominent counter-missionary Rabbi Tovia Singer said in an interview this week on The Jerusalem Post’s Sits Down With podcast.

“What's happening in Israel is a certain type of stage four cancer,” Singer warned, adding that “there is no stage five.”

“The problem in Israel has no parallel anywhere in the Diaspora,” he said, arguing that cooperation between Jewish communities and evangelical Christian Zionists, particularly over settlement in the West Bank, has created opportunities for missionary activity that are less common abroad.

Singer stressed that the Christian Zionists he was discussing genuinely support Israel and are not simply using their support as a pretext to convert Jews.

“They really believe that the Jews belong here in the land of Israel,” he said. Nevertheless, he argued, some use those relationships to introduce Jews to Christianity.

“The evangelism happens on a social level, social networking,” he said, allowing missionaries to “weaponize their relationship in order to spread the gospel.”

A protester from a group called ''Jews for Jesus'' (C) hands out flyers to a crowd arriving at the Loews Theater in New York, for the first showing of ''The Passion of the Christ'', 25 February 2004.
A protester from a group called ''Jews for Jesus'' (C) hands out flyers to a crowd arriving at the Loews Theater in New York, for the first showing of ''The Passion of the Christ'', 25 February 2004. (credit: TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP via Getty Images)

Singer pointed to Cafe Basimta, a Jerusalem coffee shop run by Jews for Jesus, as an example. He said the controversy surrounding protests against the cafe drew public attention to its ties to the missionary organization, while criticizing the protesters' conduct as verbally and emotionally abusive.

Tovia Singer: Jews for Jesus operates 'under the radar'

“And that's Jews for Jesus' plan,” Singer said. “Their plan is always to be under the radar. That's the way they operate.”

Asked whether Messianic Jewish organizations exaggerate their success at converting Jews, Singer disputed that conclusion. The question cited a 2015 study by Concordia University researcher Hillary Kaell estimating that at least 70% of participants in North American Messianic Jewish congregations were not Jewish.

“I wish I could tell you how they're exaggerating, but they're not,” Singer said.

“The vast majority of Jews who are converted to Christianity are not in Messianic congregations,” he maintained. “They're in churches.”

Singer said Jews who convert to Christianity generally join established Christian denominations, and argued that evangelical Christians, rather than professional missionaries, are often responsible for introducing Jews to the faith.

“In almost all cases, the person who succeeds in evangelizing a Jew is a Gentile Evangelical Christian, not a Jew who's already converted,” he said, pointing to relationships formed at universities and workplaces.

Singer also placed responsibility for missionary success on failures within the Jewish community, particularly in education.

“The success of Jews for Jesus and the hundreds of other missionary groups that target Jews represent the unpaid bills of the Jewish people,” he said.

Asked what he meant by “unpaid bills,” Singer responded: “We have failed in Jewish education.”

He argued that Jews with limited religious education are more vulnerable to missionary arguments, and said that “Jews for Nothing,” his term for Jews disconnected from their religious identity, pose an even greater threat to Jewish continuity than Jews for Jesus.

“The success of Jews for Jesus represents our failure to give our children a proper Jewish education,” he said.

Singer also criticized gaps in Orthodox Jewish education, saying that despite high levels of religious learning, some yeshiva students are unfamiliar with the biblical passages missionaries use to argue that Jesus was the Messiah.

“We drop the ball in one area, and that's the prophets and the writings,” he said, urging greater study of books such as Isaiah, Zechariah and Ezekiel. He also accused missionary groups of selectively publishing encounters in which Jewish students struggle to answer their questions.

Despite his criticism of Christian missionary efforts, Singer condemned incidents of anti-Christian harassment in Israel, including the spitting at Christian clergy in Jerusalem.

“If you wanna pull Christians to hate Jews more, just keep doing that,” he said. “It's a horrible thing. The Jewish community rejects it.”

Singer recalled that he once viewed Christians as enemies after experiencing antisemitic harassment growing up in Brooklyn. His attitude changed, he said, after meeting Nathaniel Nash, a Christian Zionist journalist for The New York Times who attended his lectures and later became a close friend.

“I had to change my views 180 degrees,” Singer said. Nash later died in a plane crash.

Asked about his description of attempts to convert Jews as “spiritual genocide,” Singer clarified that he did not believe Christians necessarily considered themselves to be causing harm.

“Jews for Jesus are raising some very serious questions,” he said, arguing that those questions deserved responses rather than hostility. “I believe that bad ideas should be replaced by good ideas.”

Toward the end of the interview, Singer cited Isaiah 11, alongside Isaiah 2, as the strongest biblical challenge to the Christian belief that Jesus was the Messiah. He argued that the prophesied messianic era, including an end to war and the restoration of the Temple, did not occur in the first century.

“It's simply incompatible with the Hebrew Bible,” he said.