Just as a woman’s bra cannot be one-size-fits-all, mammography alone – which has
for decades been the standard technique for diagnosing breast cancer – is no
longer suited to everyone.
Women (and a small number of men) who
inherited the BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation that raises the lifetime risk of breast
cancer to a whopping 80 percent, or those who previously contracted a breast
tumor (of the “ordinary type” or a more aggressive form involving hormones) need
more advanced imaging technologies, which have not to date been available in all
Or at least, they have been lacking until three months
ago, when Dr. Shalom Strano opened a one stop multidisciplinary Diagnostic Breast
Health Center on the third floor of Jerusalem’s Shaare Zedek Medical Center
(SZMC). Strano, a haredi-Zionist surgeon and radiologist who came on aliya from
South Africa in 1992– has spent most of his medical career focusing on breast
health, an odd choice for a man with a trim white beard and a black kippa on his
Having co-founded and directed 14 years ago Israel’s first
non-profit, free-standing (non-hospital) mammography center in Jerusalem’s Givat
Shaul quarter, he finally decided that the field has gone beyond x-rays of the
breast to detect cancer and on to an integrated, holistic approach that includes
other “modalities” such as ultra-sound and magnetic resonance instrument (MRI)
imaging as well. His team includes not only radiologists but also breast
surgeons, oncologists, social workers, plastic surgeons, pathologists,
geneticists and more.
The third floor, which accommodated no inpatients
but was a “service floor” with only an archive and storerooms, includes more
than 1,000 square meters of space, all devoted to breast health. This it follows
in the footsteps of two other SZMC special floors – one for heart disease
prevention, diagnosis, angioplasty, surgery and rehabilitation and the other for
gynecology, obstetrics and pediatrics.
With enthusiastic permission from
SZMC director-general Prof.
Jonathan Halevy, Strano saw his center built
into a modern and attractive facility in just two months. Halevy, said Strano,
was aware that “mammography always pays its way. It offers tremendous added
value to a hospital because it’s a high-profile project and brings in patients
who need Surgery, oncology, pathology and plastic surgery and all needs a highly
regarded imaging center.” Along with Strano, the hospital also absorbed into its
staff his colleague at Hala, the Rachel Nash Comprehensive Breast Clinic –
breast specialist Dr. David Gechtman, along with three imaging technicians. He
has room for one more breast physician in the new center. Strano’s new center is
integrated with the other aspects of breast care, including surgery, performed
Moshe Carmon and Dr. Oded Olsha. He expects that 100 patients a
day – or 20,000 yearly – will visit the center.
STRANO, WHOSE office
includes four computer screens – two for ordinary mammography results, one for
ultrasound and the other for MRI – studied medicine at the famed University of
Witwatersrand in Johannesburg. Then he took fellowship positions at Brigham and
Women’s Hospital in Boston and in Rochester, New York. When he returned to South
Africa, he established that country’s first dedicated, free-standing mammography
“I initially decided to do a full residency in surgery in
Johannesburg and Capetown,” Strano told The Jerusalem Post
in a long
“Half way through, for family reasons I switched from surgery
to radiology. In 1989, I met Prof.
Albert Solomon, ex-head of radiology
at Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, who returned to his native country of South
Africa for personal reasons about 25 years ago. I worked under him as a junior
consultant and and surgical registrar.
He predicted that there would be a
new mammography subspecialty and urged me to get into it. I loved the idea,
bought equipment and set up a the first private mammography practice in South
Africa. Then Prof. Yossi Frost from Kaplan Medical Center in Rehovot invited me
to work with him.”
As Strano went to a Jewish day school, spoke Hebrew
well, had visited Israel before and was “always a Zionist,” he and his wife (a
lawyer) decided to make aliya with their five children, ten aged two to 11 two
subsequently born. Upon his arrival, the South African immigrant set up Kaplan’s
mammography department and served as its director. He was later introduced to
Dr. Yitzhak Peterburg, who was director-general of Beersheba’s Soroka University
Medical Center (like Kaplan, owned by Clalit Health Services) and arranged that
he also become head of breast imaging there. There his center purchased the
first stereotactic table in Israel; such a device, on which a woman lies prone
and the breast hangs through an opening hole, became an alternative to
excisional biopsies by performing a minimally invasive procedure.
is used to pinpoint the suspected lesion cells and insert a needle to remove
them it for testing without cutting out whole pieces of tissue and causing
Then Rabbi Michoel Sorotzkin, who found funding for a
freestanding clinic, invited him to co-found Hala, funded by the late Jack Nash,
and Strano remained there as its director for 14 years, becoming Israel’s
leading breast diagnostician.
“I was very happy there, but I felt I had
reached a ceiling. Breast imaging, especially for more complicated cases, had
moved on,” Strano said, explaining his departure.
“At Hala, we had a very
strong relationship with SZMC, which sent us all their breast imaging work. When
I left, it was served by 16,000 women a year – up to 80 patients a
IT’S GOING to be unique,” Strano continued. “In the 1980s and
1990s, mammography was the only breast imaging modality.
high-quality breast ultrasound was added – and the field hit a plateau. What
changed the whole playing field was MRI and genetics. MRI always existed as a
possible modality, but genetics was a precipitating factor. Fortunately,
world-renowned SZMC medical geneticist Prof. Ephrat Levy-Lahad has long been
working there with patients who carry breast cancer genes. “She set up the Noga
clinic for BRCA patients from around the country. It is run by Dr. Pnina Mor, a
nurse with a doctorate who runs the clinic for BRCA carriers that offers
ultrasound of ovaries, a search for tumor markers, referral for mastectomy and
reconstruction and prophylactic oophorectomy [surgical removal of the ovaries].
They are all there, and they are included in the basket of health
The incidence of breast cancer in Israel is relatively high.
Between the ages of 40 and 50, 50% of women have dense breasts and little fatty
tissue. As they get older, dense breast tissue gradually turns to
“Fatty tissue appears black on a mammogram, and dense breast tissue
and tumors are white. If everything is white, you’ll miss a certain percentage
of cancers in a dense breast. One can’t see a white piece of paper on a white
wall in a white room,” Strano explained. As we moved to risk-assessed imaging,
we saw that women are not all the same. One who is over 50, has average fat
density and no family history will do fine being screened only with mammography.
in a center like Hala.
But if there’s a 40-year-old woman with dense
tissue and a higher risk of cancer, she will also need an ultrasound, which
catches things a mammogram doesn’t find. So there are fewer false negative
-positive results. And then MRIs were also introduced for breast cancer
diagnosis. Ultrasound cannot be used alone as a screening tool; Mammography MRI
is needed as a road map,” he added. And then MRIs were also introduced for
breast cancer diagnosis.
At least some of the health funds don’t want to
deal with this new development. The problem is that “statistical models for risk
are poor; each one lacks factors critical for reasonable lifetime risk
But we can’t perform an MRI on everybody. There’s a high
falsepositive rate in inexperienced hands and also a fairly high falsenegative
rate. It is not 100%. MRI has to be used with caution and skill and always in
context of mammography and perhaps ultrasound.
There is high,
intermediate and low risk, and women at higher risk should not be screened with
ultrasound or MRI alone. I realized 20 years ago that it’s ridiculous to take a
woman with a very high lifetime risk and use only mammography.
women with different risks need different imaging.”
breast cancer is not the real problem, but “underdiagnosis is. If there is no
appropriate imaging or or assessment of risk, we will not get better survival
statistics. The issue is not how many cancers you detect but which cancers –
slow growing or aggressive ones.”
He said he was “worried about
commercial abuse of breast imaging; some private centers may offer automatic
whole breast, 3-D ultrasound without obligatory mammography and not integrated
in breast imaging departments.”
Strano is also concerned that as a result
of interest spurred by the case of actress Angelina Jolie – who recently
announced she underwent a double prophylactic mastectomy to head off breast
cancer resulting from her inherited BRCA gene – there will public demand for
more MRIs for breast imaging.
“There is no need for more at present,” he
asserted. “Jolie was very brave to go public – but her decision was not
mandatory for every woman in her situation. There is a new study from Toronto
with encouraging survival figures of BRCA patients.”
screening, with the encouragement of the Israel Cancer Association, has high
compliance today, except for some sectors liked haredi and Arab women – although
their willingness to go now is improved. The different modalities have to be
Bad breast imaging is worse than no imaging.
the future hold? “There is will be isotope imaging,” said Strano. “There’s
already a US company that’s but we have to reduce working on a whole-body dose.
Whatever the modality, But it has to become cheap, fast and available. People
are also working on PET [positron emission tomography].
possibilities are CT [computerized tomography] and even fMRI [functional MRI}.
Laserlight- mediated imaging, which can be merged with ultrasound, is very
promising. Another possible modality is digital tomosynthesis, an add-on of
tomography to existing mammography units.” However, he said, it takes a long
time to develop for new technologies to mature– an average of 40 years from
laboratory bench to bedside use with the patient.”
TO MARK the opening of
the new center, SZMC will host a Breast Cancer Symposium this morning (Sunday,
July 21), with three world-renowned guest speakers and a panel
They are Dr. Armando Giuliano, executive vice-chairman of
surgery in the department of surgery at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los
Angeles; Prof. Hadassah Degani, a member of the faculty of the Weizmann
Institute of Science in Rehovot and an Israel Cancer Association funded
researcher who developed a non-invasive method to differentiate between
cancerous tumors of the breast and benign lumps; and Dr.
assistant professor at the University of Toronto and staff radiologist of breast
imaging for the University Health Network and Mount Sinai Hospital, Princess
Margaret Cancer Center in Toronto.
Stay on top of the news - get the Jerusalem Post headlines direct to your inbox!