Catherine Ashton and Ehud Barak_311.
(photo credit: Ariel Harmony / Defense Ministry)
In an indication Israel believes the Palestinian Authority will indeed take its
quest for statehood recognition to the UN in September, Defense Minister Ehud
Barak spoke in a meeting with EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton Sunday
about the need to influence the wording of the resolution likely to be brought
to the world body.
Ashton: E. J'lem construction threatens two-states
'EU may push Israel into peace talks'
Up until now senior Israeli officials have not talked
– at least publicly – about trying to affect the wording of the text the
Palestinians are expected to bring, concentrating instead on trying to get
various countries around the world to convince the PA not to go that
But on Sunday, after meeting Ashton – in Israel and the PA before
convening an informal meeting of the EU’s 27 foreign ministers on September 2
where the issue will be discussed – Barak issued a statement saying that if
renewing talks before the UN move was not possible, “it is very important that
all the players come up with a text that will emphasize the quick return to
negotiations, without an effort to impose pre-conditions on the
Up until now most of the EU’s countries have refrained from
committing on how they would vote on the resolution, saying that it depended on
Barak told Ashton that from Israel’s point of view, the PA’s
turning to the Security Council or the General Assembly were both bad and
unproductive choices. “The better path,” he said, “was to go to direct
negotiations without preconditions.”
Ashton heard a similar message from
President Shimon Peres, who said there was a need to work “around the clock and
take advantage of every opportunity to return to the negotiation
He said the UN bid was a “substantive error, since there is no
alternative to direct negotiations between the sides.” She also met with Prime
Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, but no statement was issued by either side after
Prior to meeting Ashton, Netanyahu met with Norway’s
Foreign Minister Jonas Gahr Store, in the region before his country chairs a
donors’ conference for the PA scheduled in September.
According to the
Prime Minister’s Office, Netanyahu expressed concern that the PA’s UN move could lead to violence and would hurt the “political process.” The
Palestinians have a history of “climbing up trees and then kicking out the
ladder,” he said, adding that going through with the move would be as if the PA
were abrogating previous agreements.
Netanyahu said Israel took risks and
evacuated territory on the assumption that the conflict would be settled by
negotiations, and that this was an abrogation of those understandings.
the UN indeed adopted a resolution that called for a Palestinian state based on
the June 4, 1967, lines, Netanyahu asked, did that mean that the Western Wall
was occupied territory? Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman was even more direct
with Store, saying that if the PA went through with the move he would recommend
immediately cutting off all ties with the PA.
“It is impossible that in
the morning the Palestinian Authority has security cooperation with us, and in
the evening brings legal action against us at the International Court of Justice
in The Hague,” Lieberman said.
The security cabinet met last week to
discuss how Israel would respond to the move, but no decisions – if in fact they
were reached – were made public.
Netanyahu, in his meeting with Store,
also discussed the situation in the South, and said that the reason his
government was able to show restraint last week in response to the terrorist
attack near Eilat and the missile attacks from Gaza, was because “we don’t have
to prove that we are tough.”
Earlier in the day, at a meeting of Likud
ministers, Netanyahu said that he could not say that the tension in the South
was over. Rather, he said, the situation remained tense and could flare up again
Regarding the peace treaty with Egypt, Netanyahu said that this
has stood the test of time, and he doesn’t believe it should be changed.
However, he did talk about the need to “beef up security arrangements on
Israel’s side, and speed up construction of the fence along the southern
Netanyahu said Egypt has not asked to open up the treaty and
allow for more Egyptian security forces inside Sinai, and that if such a request
were forthcoming, a decision would be made only after a meeting of the security
This statement contradicted previous reports.