Iran, where a woman convicted of adultery has been sentenced to death by stoning, is likely to become a member of the board of the new UN agency to promote equality for women, prompting outrage from the US and human rights groups.
Some rights groups are also upset that Saudi Arabia, where women are not allowed to drive and are barred from many facilities used by men, is also vying to join the governing body of UN Women.
The General Assembly resolution adopted in July that merged four UN bodies dealing with women's issues into a single agency with greater clout to represent half the world's population calls for a 41-member executive board, with 35 members chosen by regional groups and six representing donor nations.
The Asian group has put forward an uncontested 10-nation slate that includes Iran, UN diplomats said, and Saudi Arabia has been selected for one of two slots for emerging donor nations.
The 54 nations on the UN Economic and Social Council are expected to elect UN Women's board on Nov. 10, and it is possible that other Asian nations or emerging donor nations could become candidates though diplomats say it's not likely.
Mark Kornblau, spokesman for the US Mission, said Wednesday that Iran's membership "would send the wrong signal at the start of this exciting new initiative."
"UN Women is a vital new agency tasked with promoting gender equality and women's empowerment worldwide," he said. "We and many other countries are concerned by the negative implications of Iran's potential board memberships, given its poor record on human rights and the treatment of women.
"There are many qualified countries that would make positive and constructive contributions as board members," Kornblau said.
The stoning sentence against the 43-year-old woman, Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani, has raised an international outcry, embarrassing Iran.
A resolution adopted by the General Assembly last year expressed "deep concern" at Iran's increasing use of executions, death by stoning, torture, flogging and amputations, and its increasing discrimination against religious, ethnic and other minorities.
Philippe Bolopion, UN advocacy director for Human Rights Watch, said "it's puzzling that Iran would have the nerve to be a candidate for the board of UN Women, and even more puzzling if the Asia group lets Iran get away with it."
"Having on top of it Saudi Arabia, a country with a track record on women's rights as horrendous as Iran's, would add insult to injury," he said.
Bolopion called their potential membership "an affront to women around the world who are placing their hopes in UN Women," but he expressed hope that the board's overall composition will ensure that neither country will be able to use their position to undermine the agency's work.
Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon chose former Chilean president Michelle
Bachelet to head UN Women, an appointment greeted with overwhelming
approval by governments and women's groups who campaigned for four years
to streamline the UN's activities promoting the status of women.
The framework for UN Women's work is the platform to achieve women's
equality adopted by 189 nations at the 1995 UN women's conference in
Beijing. It called for governments to end discrimination against women
and close the gender gap in 12 critical areas including health,
education, employment, political participation and human rights.
Bolopion and Jose Luis Diaz, Amnesty International's UN representative,
were critical of regional groups pre-selecting candidates instead of
allowing a contested election in which countries choose candidates and
reject ones they deem unqualified.
"Sadly, the issue is not just an individual country's track record on
women's rights, dismal though that may be," Diaz said. "A clean slate
guarantees countries a seat in the executive body, regardless of their
record in protecting women's rights or promoting gender equality. The
failure to ensure competitive elections is the responsibility of all
Cora Weiss, president of the Hague Appeal for Peace, said that if board
membership "helps to influence Iran's attitude toward women then fine,
but if Iran uses it to hold back our dreams and vision for equality then
it's a disaster."
According to UN diplomats, the 10 countries selected by the Asian group
for the board are Iran, Bangladesh, India, China, Malaysia, Indonesia,
South Korea, Japan, Kazakhstan and Pakistan. Eastern Europe and Latin
America have put forward contested slates, the diplomats said, speaking
on condition of anonymity because the lists have not been made public.
The resolution earmarks four seats from the 10 top donor nations and
diplomats said the candidates are the United States, Britain, Spain and
Norway. It allocated two seats to contributors from developing countries
and diplomats said the candidates are Saudi Arabia and Mexico.