Mother and daughter child custody 390.
(photo credit: Thinkstock/Imagebank)
The heads of two prominent Knesset committees cautioned Tuesday against hurrying
to cancel a 50-year-old law that automatically awards custody of children under
six to their mothers in divorce cases.
“The law needs to be evaluated
further, but I would not cancel this arrangement automatically because there has
not been a significant enough change in cultural attitudes that warrants
reversing it by 180 degrees,” commented MK Zevulun Orlev (Habayit Hayehudi),
chairman of the Committee for the Rights of the Child.
with MK Tzipi Hotovely (Likud), chairwoman of the Committee on the Status of
Women, heard from a Justice Ministry panel that had recommended repealing
Article 25 of the Capacity and Guardianship Law, known as the Tender Years
Presumption Law. Panel members says the move would make custody arrangements
Speaking on Tuesday at the Knesset, Prof. Dan Schnitt,
who has headed the panel for the past five years, explained that attempts had
been made to hear from “everyone who has a position on this subject.”
said it had been very difficult to find a balance on the issue, but that the
goal was to ensure that children from divorced families had access to both
parents. He added that it was up to the courts to consider equality and
stability in the child’s life.
During Tuesday’s hearing, the debate over
Schnitt’s recommendations became quite stormy, with one person being escorted
out by security guards. On one side, women’s rights groups such as Naamat and
the Women’s International Zionist Organization (WIZO) argued that without
greater equality for women in society, each custody dispute would turn into an
ugly, drawn-out case involving the children. On the other side, fathers’ groups
argued about their rights to a fair hearing and to having access to their
Hotovely criticized the debate, saying it was turning children
into “objects,” and that while the desire for equality was legitimate it was
coming at the expense of the children.
“Every child should live in one
house and not be forced to pack up his or her belongings every two
days. Adults would not be able to stand up to that disruption. It
is turning the children into the battle ground,” she said.
Hotovely and Orlev agreed that the existing law is possibly outdated and might
need to be changed to create more gender equality in custody arrangements, both
urged that it not be done in haste.
Orlev suggested that perhaps it
should come gradually, with the age of the so-called tender years presumption
being reduced from six to four over the next half-decade.
He ordered the
Knesset Information and Research Department to study the statistics for a
follow-up session scheduled to take place in the coming months.
most of the Knesset members present at Tuesday’s hearing also cautioned against
hasty changes, MK Yulia Shamalov Berkovich (Israel Beiteinu) said the current
arrangement was hurtful not only for fathers who do not receive custody of their
children, but also for paternal grandparents and other relatives on the father’s
side. She said that many people, including divorced mothers who want to see the
law changed, had approached her.
“Divorced mothers also feel that fathers
should be involved in raising their young children. They want help from their
husbands,” Shamalov Berkovich said. “It should not be that after a divorce men
can shake off all responsibility while women have to stay at home and care for
Shamalov Berkovich has already drafted a private member’s
bill aimed at replacing the Tender Years Presumption Law with a more
Join Jerusalem Post Premium Plus now for just $5 and upgrade your experience with an ads-free website and exclusive content. Click here>>