Women work at a factory in Israel 390.
(photo credit: Ariel Jerozolimski)
Two of my “friends” on Facebook started going at it, as Facebook people often
do, over my recent column analyzing the failure of Palestinian activists to
achieve any of their goals.
The debate quickly got off-topic and started
careening over the cliff of Palestinian-Israeli futility at a very high speed.
It became obvious that neither was really listening to the other. Both were
repeating the same old arguments that have muddled Palestinian-Israeli peace
It reminded me what the real problem Palestinians and Israeli
face is: We don’t really care much about peace. We just like to argue.
Arguing is a waste of time, of course. I know that when I write my columns
“arguing” a “fact,” most Israelis won’t listen to me. They don’t listen to me
period, based on the talkbacks to my columns here.
It’s a waste of time
because the purpose of arguing isn’t to convince someone to change their mind.
It’s a selfish exercise in ego and pride. We say things to each other to make
ourselves feel as if we have struck a blow against the other. It’s a kind of
twisted form of punishment.
No amount of arguing will change the futility
of the failed peace process. We can blame each other, but it won’t
matter. What will matter is if we decided to simply accept the reality of our
circumstances. Palestinians believe something and Israelis believe something
And if we accept that, then we must also accept the realization
that the only real option is to look ahead, not backwards. Arguing is about
“looking backwards.” Looking backwards is not the same as “remembering” or
“never forgetting.” I am not advocating that Palestinians or Israelis forget the
atrocities that each have inflicted on the other. I am also not saying we should
ignore the tragedies of history that have brought us to the edge of the abyss
where most Israelis and Palestinians stand oblivious to the impending dangers
that lie ahead of us if we fail to achieve peace.
I am saying that it is
okay to accept the fact that Palestinians and Israelis basically live in two
different realities. Palestinians believe something and Israelis believe
something else. We could remain like this forever, teetering on the edge of
disaster. The disaster could be a modern-day Armageddon. Personally,
that’s the dark future I see for Israelis and Palestinians.
heritage is being slowly and steadily erased by Israeli stubbornness and
arrogance. Israelis refuse to show compassion to Palestinians. To me that
is odd coming from a people who suffered so much. But someone once explained
that people who suffer are less likely to be magnanimous or generous when power
returns to them.
Israelis are living in a hallucination of peace. They
feel a sense of victory as they watch the secular Palestinians who have argued
for two states steadily vanish. What remains is the growing Islamic movement,
which is far more powerful than Palestinian secularism ever could hope to be.
The Islamic movement will soon have total control over the region, and they are
very less likely to compromise.
Israelis are great at seeing the essence
of the moment, but their vision becomes blurred when they have to look far down
the road. This explains their long-term strategy, which is really a short-term
strategy – Israelis take whatever they can get, and usually get “everything,”
while Arabs demand everything and usually get nothing.
What we need is
for both sides to start respecting each other again, instead of always trying to
insult each other with arguments about “facts.”
When it comes to the
Palestine- Israel conflict, there are no facts.
What we need to do is
accept a foundation for peace. Palestinians recognize Israel and Israelis
recognize Palestine. No violence, no expansion of settlements, and end to the
hatred from both sides.
It sounds so simple, but as we know, it’s not.
It’s actually easier to argue incessantly than it is to overcome our emotions
and make compromises for peace.Ray Hanania is a Palestinian American
columnist and radio talk show host.www.YallaPeace.com.