Sentence too lenient
Sir, – Anat Kamm believes her sentence should be reduced
because of the relatively light sentence it seems Uri Blau will serve
(“Following Blau verdict, Supreme Court hears Anat Kamm’s appeal for lighter
sentence,” July 31).
Having watched (in frustrated indignation) the plea
bargains and lighter sentences handed down recently by our faulty justice
system, I am really afraid that Kamm might get her way.
She, who decided
that she had the right to release important state secrets, endangered our
country, our army and, even more vile, colleagues who served with her. She had
no idea of the damage her espionage would do and might still do.
not deserve one day less in prison. Her very lenient sentence was a travesty.
Let it not become a joke.
Jerusalem Dubious generalities
Sir, – Kenneth Wald’s “The facts about the Jewish vote in the US” (July 31) is
of minimal predictive value, for while Jews have, on average, voted mostly
Democrat, the rate has fluctuated widely.
President Clinton got 80
percent of the Jewish vote in 1992, yet President Carter managed just 45% in
1980. Republican presidents Eisenhower, Nixon, Reagan and George H.W. Bush
secured 35%-40% of the Jewish vote, yet other Republican candidates barely
Thus, trying to extrapolate the 2012 Jewish vote from
averaging such data is akin to trying to predict Election Day weather based on
that of previous Election Days.
Furthermore, Wald ignores current facts
and trends that are more pertinent. Recent polling already shows a 14% drop in
President Barack Obama’s Jewish support since 2008. Among Jews focused on
national security and US-Israel relations, Romney leads Obama, 45% to
Obama’s Jewish campaign contributions are far below 2008 levels. And
polling of American Jews living in Israel, who are about evenly split in party
affiliation, shows Obama drawing less than 30% of their votes.
year America’s most Jewish congressional district, in New York and always
reliably Democrat, elected a Republican for the first time since the Harding
The Jewish vote plays an outsized role in many states. In
Florida Jews make up about 9% of the electorate. Thus, even a 10-point swing of
Jewish votes away from Obama can shift the election dramatically.
November, will Obama poll more like Clinton or Carter? I have my guess – and it
is based on more than Wald’s dubious generalities.
Jerusalem The writer is counsel for Republicans Abroad Israel Not the time
– I came to Jerusalem in July of 1959. King George Street was my favorite walk
every morning on the way to work.
It was not renamed when Israel became a
free state. It also stayed the same after 1967, when Jerusalem was
I don’t know if we should change it at all (“Last signs of
Britain,” Letters, July 31). One thing I am sure of – it is the wrong time. We
need friends, not more enemies.
OLGA P. WIND
Holon That editorial
After reading the angry letters (“Horrendous editorial, July 31) that were
critical of “Tisha Be’Av’s meaning” (July 29), I went back to the original
piece, which had not inspired the same ire in me, to see if there was something
I came to the conclusion that both sides had missed some
The derogatory usage of the term “holy slaughterhouse,”
in describing the Temple, implies a misunderstanding of its role and why its
absence today is so glaring.
Whether or not animal sacrifice is
reinstated at the time of the final redemption is perhaps debatable even in the
framework of traditional Jewish thought – Maimonides believed that God’s
decision to allow sacrifices was a concession to human psychological
limitations. But the concept of God’s presence among His people is the main
theme of the Temple for which we mourn and yearn, and it is as relevant today as
it’s been for the past 2,000 years.
On the other hand, while reading
descriptions of a desolate, barren Jerusalem in Lamentations, we cannot help but
be struck by the contrast to the thriving city that is our nation’s capital. For
that reason the facts iterated in the piece pointing to our still precarious
situation are worth pondering on the day of mourning, when we beseech God to
restore His place among us and, in so doing, finally obliterate the threats from
those who still seek our destruction.
Rehovot Who’s the
Sir, – When reading Sarah Honig’s “From Jean-Baptiste to Bon Jovi”
(Another Tack, July 27) and learning about the American- sponsored Global
Terrorism Forum, I was reminded of what I read 14 years ago in a Swedish
Evangelical weekly magazine: “Laos is a forgotten country....
years, between 1964 and 1973, the American aerial combat powers
dropped... bombs over Laos every eight minutes, around the clock. They
also dropped all kinds of poison, which contaminated water and destroyed the
harvests. Laos has suffered the results of the Vietnam War to this day.... [A]t
least one person is killed every second day because of old, undetonated
The article continues with further examples of American
Id anything has been rectified from the American side I have not
yet read about it.
Sir, – I was
surprised by Sir Paul McCartney’s choice of “Hey Jude” to herald the lighting of
the Olympic flame. I thought the song not suitable – until I realized that this
was his personal salute to the victims of the Munich massacre.
we all know, is German for Jew. In Sir Paul’s own words (The Beatles Anthology,
courtesy of Wikipedia): “I went into the Apple shop just before ‘Hey Jude’ was
being released. The windows were whited-out, and I thought: ‘Great opportunity.
Baker Street, millions of buses going around....’ So, before anyone knew what it
meant, I scraped “Hey Jude” out of the whitewash.
A guy who had a
delicatessen in Marylebone rang me up, and he was furious: ‘I’m going to send
one of my sons round to beat you up.’ I said, ‘Hang on, hang on – what’s this
about?,’ and he said: ‘You’ve written Jude in the shop window.’ I had no idea it
meant Jew.... I swear it never occurred to me.”
“Hey Jude” – a salute to
the victims of Munich and a barb directed at the IOC. Brilliantly done, Sir
Montreal ...vs Gilady
Sir, – The International Olympic
Committee not once, but twice, kicked Israel in the teeth at the London
First, it refused to hold a minute of silence in memory of the
Israeli sportsmen murdered at the Munich Games in 1972.
Then, at last
Friday’s opening, the camera broke away as each country’s Olympic squad entered
the stadium to show its head of state, head of government or other national
But when the Israeli sportsmen entered, the camera showed
Alex Gilady instead of Culture and Sport Minister Limor Livnat.
Gilady? Is it because this Israeli is senior vice-president at NBC Sports, the
US network that won the contract to televise the Olympics, or because he is the
member of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) in charge of media
relations? Knowing Gilady for many years I am convinced that, if he had wanted
to, he could have persuaded the IOC to observe a minute of silence. Does the old
adage “Being more Catholic than the pope” apply here?