June 1: Influence in high places

Is being the son of the president's chief of staff enough to abrogate halacha?

By JPOST READERS
June 1, 2010 11:22
letters

letters. (photo credit: JP)

 
X

Dear Reader,
As you can imagine, more people are reading The Jerusalem Post than ever before. Nevertheless, traditional business models are no longer sustainable and high-quality publications, like ours, are being forced to look for new ways to keep going. Unlike many other news organizations, we have not put up a paywall. We want to keep our journalism open and accessible and be able to keep providing you with news and analyses from the frontlines of Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World.

As one of our loyal readers, we ask you to be our partner.

For $5 a month you will receive access to the following:

  • A user experience almost completely free of ads
  • Access to our Premium Section
  • Content from the award-winning Jerusalem Report and our monthly magazine to learn Hebrew - Ivrit
  • A brand new ePaper featuring the daily newspaper as it appears in print in Israel

Help us grow and continue telling Israel’s story to the world.

Thank you,

Ronit Hasin-Hochman, CEO, Jerusalem Post Group
Yaakov Katz, Editor-in-Chief

UPGRADE YOUR JPOST EXPERIENCE FOR 5$ PER MONTH Show me later Don't show it again

Influence in high places

Sir, – Leaving politics out for a moment and looking at things from the perspective of Halacha, why did Rahm Emanuel’s son merit to read from the Torah on a Sunday morning (“Rahm Emanuel’s family follows boys’ bar mitzva with mitzva,” May 31)?

Be the first to know - Join our Facebook page.


The established principle, as codified in the Shulchan Aruch, is public readings being made on Mondays and Thursdays. Is being the son of the president’s chief of staff enough to abrogate Halacha?

ZE’EV M. SHANDALOV
Ma'ale Adumim
The writer is a rabbi.

Scrutinize those bills

 Sir, – Having read “PA officials consider replacing Israeli shekel with Palestinian pound” (May 31), I assume that if the Palestinian Authority re-issues the British Mandate-era Palestinian pound to replace the Israeli shekel in areas under their control, they will take care to remove any Hebrew inscriptions that appeared on the original notes – especially those that include an abbreviation of the term Eretz Yisrael, the Land of Israel.

YONATAN SILVER
Jerusalem



Dwindling generation

Sir, – I would like to thank you for your piece on the passing of Lova Eliav (“Arie ‘Lova’ Eliav, one of the last living members of Israel’s greatest generation,’ dies at 88,” May 31).

There are very few left of that greatest generation. We need them badly in these turbulent times. Oh, if only they could show our “leaders" the way.”

LEONARD ZURAKOV
Netanya

How does he know?

Sir, – Visiting Gaza months months after the fact, it is remarkable that Dr. Peter Voss can come to any conclusion at all (“Nightmare of whose doing?” Letters, May 31). He mentions the “senseless destruction visible everywhere.” Do your homework, Dr. Voss, and maybe ask someone besides a Hamas representative about the actual sequence of events.

MARCELLA WACHTEL
Jerusalem

Get out the word...

Sir, – Regarding “Desperate housewives don’t count rockets, they count days” (May 30), the fundamental objective of both Hamas and Hizbullah is the total destruction of Israel, a sovereign country. Because of this, they are a threat to world peace and they force Israel to act in self defense.

Unfortunately, our politicians and diplomats have failed to keep this simple fact in the public eye. As a result, both organizations are gaining respectability while our enemies’ lies are being believed and the truth ignored.

We must now go on a hasbara offensive with this simple, clear message.  It cannot be repeated too often or stressed too much.

CLIVE LEIGH
Netanya

... in a positive way, please

Sir, – I am a housewife who went through all the wars, starting in 1948, when I was in the Givati Brigade. My husband, son and grandchildren served in the army.

Do you want to demoralize us? Why do you make us look as  if we have no answer to anything our enemies might prepare for us?

We were strong up to now. We were always proud of what we achieved and have every right to be. Does Amir Mizroch want to break our morale?

A.R. KATZ
Kfar Saba

How good we have it

Sir, – After reading columnists David Horovitz and Caroline Glick (“Only a drill?” and “Netanyahu, Obama’s newest prop,” May 28), wherein Mr. Horovitz’s assessments of the dire straights of Israeli lives and security, and then Ms. Glick’s take on Obama’s closing the door on Israel and leaving the Jews to the wolves, I am more alarmed than ever.

I sit here in the Diaspora – free of daily terror, free of angst from missiles falling at any moment, free of nuclear threats from a crazy man who has the power and means to deliver on them, free of the fear for my children and grandchildren from fanatical and hateful neighboring anti-Semitic countries – and think of how each and every Israeli is not.

I implore all Jews throughout the Diaspora to protect themselves by protecting and defending Israel at each and every opportunity, with all means at their disposal. It’s a giant step in moving Israel out of the bulls-eye and a small step in self preservation.

HOWARD WOLLE
Toronto

Sir, – David Horovitz’s analysis “Only a drill?” points out Israel’s untenable position if it allows its combined enemies first blood in the next war. But Horovitz stops short of the obvious: Israel must strike first and strike hard, perhaps even using nuclear weapons.

Yes, the world will howl but Israel mustn’t care – your survival is at stake. Those missiles aren’t aligned against you for nothing – they are there to be used whenever your enemies feel bold enough. Why allow them the initiative?

ABE KRIEGER
Highland Park, New Jersey

Living it down

Sir, – It is hard for me to believe that Larry Derfner, a veteran writer and resident in Israel, is naive enough to believe that the supplies sent on the “Freedom Flotilla” boats, even if they were allowed to land safely in Gaza, would be distributed to those people for whom they were intended (“Living it up in Gaza,” May 27).

Past experience has shown that Hamas confiscates aid and either uses it for its troops, sells it to the population or uses it in a way to control the population. The worse the situation is in Gaza, the better it is for Hamas. Considering how generous Israel has been with an enemy population, Hamas must be working very hard to keep the Arab population depressed.

PAUL BERMAN
Shoham

Do it right

Sir, – Jeremy Last sums up a soccer fan’s feelings as we go into the World Cup (“Riding the failures to reach greater heights,” May 28).

We can and will enjoy the atmosphere, camaraderie and, no doubt, amazing football, but if we are to expect our own national team to reach these heights, we will need an Israeli “academy of excellence,” where soccer is nurtured from an early age.

MARTIN LEWIS
Hod Hasharon

A beauty by any standards

Sir , – Ray Hanania claims that this year’s Miss USA, Lebanese-American Rima Fakih, overcame the “de facto essence of American beauty” and thereby “reset the definition of American beauty” (“Bikinis versus burkas,” May 26).

Hanania assumes that any absence of success by Arab-Americans is due to racism. This offers Arab-Americans an excuse that removes personal responsibility. It also allows them to not even try since they can assume from the outset that they have no chance of succeeding.

This is offensive to both Arab-Americans and American society as a whole. Why not simply congratulate Ms. Fakih for her achievement? She deserved to win – not because or in spite of her Lebanese heritage, but because she is stunningly beautiful by anyone’s standards.

EFRAIM A. COHEN
Netanya

Rationalizations of the Left

Sir, – There is something about the Left that smacks of neurosis, a symptom of which is the following:  Having failed to bring about the success of his efforts, using the same methods over and again, the neurotic person insists that this time it will work. Undeviating in his approach, he stubbornly presses on. When it fails again, as it must, he is certain it will work next time.

I end my description of Gershon Baskin and his ilk (“Bring in the third parties,” May 25). Having lived through or known of the uselessness of national and international guarantees for Israel’s security, what does Baskin propose to insure Palestinian adherence to a peace agreement? Of course: international promises to use military and political means for Israel's viability.

If only Baskin would read history, he would understand the folly of.... Whom am I kidding? He would find rationalizations to brush aside 2,000 years of historical fact as well.

BERNARD SMITH
Jerusalem

Related Content

Letters
August 19, 2018
Letters to the Editor: August 20, 2018

By LETTERS TO THE EDITOR