Rabbi Ovadia Yosef 311.
(photo credit: Courtesy)
Never one to shy away from controversy, spiritual leader of the Shas movement
Rabbi Ovadia Yosef delivered a broadside Saturday night against secular schools
and the secular courts system.
While giving his weekly Torah lesson from
his home in the ultra-Orthodox Jerusalem neighborhood of Har Nof, Yosef said
that anyone who sends their children to a secular school or turns to the civil
courts system instead of the religious courts for legal redress cannot lead
prayers services in synagogue.
Yosef denounced anyone who goes to state
courts rather than religious ones, to resolve legal disputes – something that is
forbidden by Torah law – as “evil,” and explained that the secular courts do not
rule in accordance with Jewish law and are hostile to it.
his point, he alluded to the ruling of the High Court of Justice in February
that yeshiva students can no longer indefinitely defer their military
“A Jew who goes to the courts of non-Jews in order that it
should judge a case, and not to a rabbinical court, is forbidden from leading
prayer services,” Yosef said. “Today this [principle] is cheapened [and] people
go to the secular courts, which rule against the Torah... We see [the courts’]
behavior against the Torah, against yeshiva students; they have no love for
Torah, they hate the Torah,” Yosef said.
He also criticized anyone who
works with the state justice system as a judge and said that such a person is
invalid as a witness in a rabbinical court and cannot lead prayers in
“There is no doubt all the judges in the secular court system
are ineligible as witnesses, you can’t take them to a wedding to sign on a
marriage certificate, it is forbidden... someone who does so... it is as if
there was no wedding.”
Yosef related an incident in which he invalidated
a marriage certificate, because one of the witnesses had been a judge in the
state court system, and told the couple to get married again. He added that
anyone who uses such witnesses at his wedding subsequently engages in illicit
sexual relations when he sleeps with his wife because the witness, and thus the
marriage, is invalid.
Expounding on the principle, Yosef said that
someone who “presides in the court system of non-Jews which rule on the basis of
non-Jewish law, lifts up his hands against the Torah of Moses our teacher and is
called an evil person. They rule according to the laws of the nations of the
world, not the Torah, and they accept the testimony of women.”
Gilad Kariv, director of the Reform Movement in Israel, said in response to
Yosef’s remarks that they should not be taken lightly by the Israeli
“This is the educational platform being used to teach tens of
thousands of students, who are nursed on the hatred and deep contempt for the
secular public and state institutions of Rabbi Yosef’s teachings,” Kariv
“In light of these words, it is fitting that leaders of the state
cease their pilgrimages and marches of flattery to the rabbi’s house, and
publicly and politically renounce themselves from him and his teachings,” Kariv