IDF grants religious woman exemption after snafu

Army arrested Fanny Yitzhak as a ‘draft dodger’ although she had already performed alternative service.

November 30, 2010 03:15
4 minute read.
Illustrative photo: Soldier praying.

311_Army chick praying. (photo credit: Marc Israel Sellem)


Dear Reader,
As you can imagine, more people are reading The Jerusalem Post than ever before. Nevertheless, traditional business models are no longer sustainable and high-quality publications, like ours, are being forced to look for new ways to keep going. Unlike many other news organizations, we have not put up a paywall. We want to keep our journalism open and accessible and be able to keep providing you with news and analysis from the frontlines of Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World.

As one of our loyal readers, we ask you to be our partner.

For $5 a month you will receive access to the following:

  • A user experience almost completely free of ads
  • Access to our Premium Section
  • Content from the award-winning Jerusalem Report and our monthly magazine to learn Hebrew - Ivrit
  • A brand new ePaper featuring the daily newspaper as it appears in print in Israel

Help us grow and continue telling Israel’s story to the world.

Thank you,

Ronit Hasin-Hochman, CEO, Jerusalem Post Group
Yaakov Katz, Editor-in-Chief


Fanny Yitzhak may have completed her national service, but for the past two months, as far as the IDF was concerned, she was nothing but another draft-dodger.

Yitzhak, who has spent a large part of this month in IDF detention, was the subject of a hearing in the Knesset’s State Control Committee on Monday.

Woman detained for 'draft-dodging' despite national service
Regev: Bill draft-dodging by religious women not a failure

The Jerusalem Post was told, even before Yitzhak found out, that after an MK’s intervention and the publication of her story, the army would finally give her the exemption from IDF service to which she was entitled.

Yitzhak, the daughter of Ethiopian immigrants, volunteered for national service after finishing high school. She completed her stint at Clalit’s Center for Child Development in Jaffa in September and began to work at a local gas station while considering her academic future. But the 19-year-old did not foresee that a part of that future would be spent as an unwilling guest of the IDF.

“On November 1, the day before my sister’s wedding, the Military Police came to my house at 3 a.m. to take me to the Tel Hashomer Induction Base. They said that I was a draft-evader,” Yitzhak recalled.

“I told them that I finished national service with distinction, and they said, ‘Bring your papers, and if everything is in order, they’ll release you in the morning.’” Four hours later, at the base, Yitzhak was woken up, placed in handcuffs, and informed that she was about to be inducted into the IDF. Yitzhak, who was supposed to spend the day chaperoning her sister as she prepared for her wedding, refused. She was taken before a tribunal and tried, but managed to convince them to allow her to go home for the wedding and then report back to Tel Hashomer for her punishment.

When she reported back to Tel Hashomer, the same routine was repeated. Once again, she was sent from office to office, and was ultimately told that the only way she could get a hearing to prove that she was not a draft-dodger was to agree to be inducted.

The source of Yitzhak’s sorrows, it turned out, was a bureaucratic slip-up that she had made two years earlier.

Yitzhak, a religiously observant girl from a religious family, had decided as a high school student that “the framework of national service was more appropriate for me, because I’m religious and... the environment would be better.”

In accordance with IDF requirements, Yitzhak appeared before the local rabbinate and made a declaration that she was religiously observant and exempt from the draft.

Yitzhak didn’t realize, however, that she also had to either present the statement in person to her local draft board or send it via certified mail to the IDF in order to receive a formal draft exemption.

“The national service didn’t ask me for any documentation regarding the exemption,” said Yitzhak. “All the documents that I knew I had to give them, I took care of; I did everything on time, and started my service in advance of many of my friends.”

During her service, Yitzhak claims, IDF representatives called her to check on her draft status, and Yitzhak faxed them her statement from the rabbinate.

When the IDF stopped calling, she assumed that the problem was resolved.

Instead, after returning from her sister’s wedding, Yitzhak was sentenced to seven days’ detention at Tel Hashomer for refusing once again to be inducted. When a staff-sergeant- major ordered her to do menial labor on the base during her detention, Yitzhak again refused, as she had not been inducted. As punishment, the soft-spoken Yitzhak was tried again and sentenced to an additional five days’ detention.

Last week, after being released, she reported for yet another series of hearings on her case.

“They asked me why I thought I was better than girls who serve two years in the army. I said that I didn’t think that I was better, but that as a religious girl, I didn’t have to do anything at all, and I volunteered for national service,” she recounted.

“I said that this was all new to me because I don’t have any connections to the army, and I didn’t understand how the paperwork was supposed to be completed,” she added.

The four-person panel that heard her case returned split, with some recommending that she be required to complete a year of IDF service, and some members recommending that she be released from her obligation.

But in response to questions from the Post, the IDF revealed Sunday night that “the Exemptions Committee decided to grant her the draft exemption that she seeks.”

The IDF noted that “Fanny Yitzhak did not normalize her status as required before beginning national service, leading to her being listed with the Manpower Division as a deserter.”

“I hope that it is true that the army has decided to release me, so that I can continue with my life,” said Yitzhak in response.

On Monday, the State Control Committee heard her story, after National Union Party Chairman Ya’acov Katz took up her case and called for the IDF and national service-sponsoring organizations to examine their procedures.

“You don’t need to take anyone, even a man, in the middle of the night. You can contact the person by phone, by mail, but not to immediately resort to coming to their house at 3 a.m.,” complained Katz’s spokesman, Harel Kohen.

Join Jerusalem Post Premium Plus now for just $5 and upgrade your experience with an ads-free website and exclusive content. Click here>>

Related Content

idf hebron
August 22, 2014
Palestinians throw Molotov cocktail at IDF checkpoint in Hebron