Main Street's soaring sour loans

Even as record profits reemerge on Wall Street, the pain on Main Street is as profound as it's been in half a century.

bike smoothie 88 248 (photo credit: )
bike smoothie 88 248
(photo credit: )
As the effects of the economic collapse began pouring down Main Street, the US government last year was left holding a record $2.1 billion in write-offs of small-business loans it had guaranteed. Officials expect the number of defaults to rise as the nation continues to climb out of the recession. Records obtained under the federal Freedom of Information Act show the public is paying to offset bank losses on small-business loans across the country, from a convenience store in the tiny Canadian border town of Houlton, Maine, to a graphic-arts design company on the island of Hawaii, more than 8,000 kilometers away. Despite having loans written off, little companies such as Caffe Sportivo - an espresso shop and small gym in Redwood City, California - are barely scraping by. "I just couldn't make any payments. I was barely making rent or payroll," owner Chris Sakelarios said on a recent afternoon when her cafe stood empty except for two patrons who read as they sipped coffee. "The same as everyone else. We're in a hovering pattern." It's a sign that even as record profits reemerge on Wall Street, thanks to massive government loans and guarantees for banks deemed too big to fail, the pain on Main Street is as profound as it's been in half a century. The companies that were not too big to fail are failing. Their plight is a shift from previous recessions when small business bounced back ahead of big employers, said Todd McCracken, president of the lobby group National Small Business Association. "This could be the first economic recovery we've seen in a long time that hits small business the hardest the longest," he said. The Small Business Administration purchased $2.1b. in bad loans from lenders last year. Agency officials say it's likely that this year will see another high as the recession nears two years. "It's frustrating when [banks] are getting bailed out for bad decisions they made, that there isn't more assistance for the small business," said Eric Geedey, who manages Caffe Sportivo for Sakelarios. Sakelarios obtained a $20,000 SBA loan from Union Bank in late 2007 to start her business when the economic outlook was more positive on the affluent San Francisco Peninsula. Within a year, however, she was scraping by with the help of a landlord and vendors who let her adjust payments. She has reduced the hours of her seven employees and relies on her brother and a friend to help keep the doors open on weekends. The balance of the loan was written off in early January. In addition to being dogged by bad credit, the cafe will have to report the loan charge-off as taxable income, Geedey said. Sakelarios isn't the only recession victim and she won't be the last. SBA loan defaults generally occur in two stages. The first is when the bank decides it won't get its money back and asks the government for the guaranteed portion of the loan. In the second, the government decides it won't receive any more collateral or money from the borrower. Years can elapse between the time that the borrower stops paying and the government writes off the loan. In 2008, for example, the government concluded it wouldn't be able to recover $1.3b. in defaulted bank loans it had guaranteed. Many loans were part of a backlog, according to SBA officials. But an AP analysis found that the time between loan approvals and loan defaults is narrowing. According to the analysis: • More than $235 million in restaurant loans have been charged off since 2007. The 2,586 restaurant charge-offs make up the largest number of defaulted loans, according to the SBA. More than 150 loans made to Quiznos franchises - worth nearly $15.5m. - have been written off since 2007. • The Gulf Coast fishing industry, battered by two major hurricanes in 2005, has been hit especially hard. Half of the 10 cities with the highest industry-specific write-offs are in Biloxi, Mississippi; New Orleans; Ocean Springs, Mississippi; Lafayette, Louisiana; and Abbeville, Louisiana. All told, the shellfish fishing industry had 45 loans charged off, at a total cost of $19.5m. • The banks making the loans have also been hit hard by the recession. Bank of America Corp., which has received $52.5b. in government aid, has had nearly 7,000 loans worth $238m. charged off since 2007. More than 660 loans worth $174m. have been charged off by CIT Group Inc., a major commercial lender forced to turn to bondholders in an effort to try to avoid bankruptcy protection after the government refused to save the company. JPMorgan Chase & Co., which repaid $25b. in taxpayer loans last month, has written off nearly 2,300 loans worth $117m. "I have never seen it as rough as it is right now," said Scott Hauge, president of Small Business California, a business advocacy group. Small businesses account for half of all private-sector workers and have created roughly half of America's jobs over the past decade. They received some help from the $787b. federal stimulus package in February, including higher micro-lending amounts and federal loan guarantees. Congress also authorized the US Treasury to purchase $15b. in pooled loans to encourage lenders to provide money to small companies. The SBA recently announced it will guarantee short-term bank loans to help small businesses pay off existing bills. The White House has floated a proposal to take money from a $700b. bailout of the financial system and provide small companies with working capital, allowing them to add inventory and employees. If it happens, the White House said, help might arrive by fall. That's too late for thousands of defunct companies with shuttered windows, disconnected phones and broken dreams. Diego Garcia's soccer supply store in the modest northern California city of Richmond has shrunk to one small location after he was forced to close his two larger stores last year. Garcia started the business after launching a youth program and soccer league in gang-ridden Richmond. He had turned away from his own gang lifestyle after being shot in the chest at age 18. Garcia expanded fast, never imagining how quickly his booming business would decline. When he couldn't pay up, his bank wrote off nearly all of his $45,000 loan. He lost rental property to foreclosure at the same time. "It's too much of a loss," Garcia said. "We had to get loans to get bigger. Then everything went the opposite way." Eric Zarnikow, SBA's associate administrator for capital access, said the bad numbers probably will continue to rise as the agency receives charged-off loans in the future from defaults occurring now. Sakelarios, a breast-cancer survivor without health insurance, tries to stay optimistic. "Anytime anyone asks me how it's going," she said, "I say the same thing: 'It's going really good.'"