RSS | Advertise With Us | Blogs | Judaica Gifts |  4 Kislev 5770, Saturday, November 21, 2009 13:12 IST |
WebJPost.com 
Subscribe! Judaica Gifts
RSS Feeds E-mail Edition
HomeHeadlinesIranian ThreatJewish WorldOpinionBusinessReal EstateLocal IsraelBlogsArts & Culture Français Classifieds
IsraelMiddle EastInternationalHealth & Sci-TechFeaturesTravelCafe OlehMagazineSportsIsrael GuideSubscribe
Specials
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers a 20% discount on online reservations
Israeli Basketball
Watch Live Israeli Premier Basketball Games
Jerusalem Post Lite
Light Edition of the Jerusalem Post for English improvement
Desert lodging & activity
Tents, camping & cabins, various activities and meals in the Negev
The Best Jewish Charity
Learn how Efrat saved 30,000 lives of Jewish children
Tamir Rent a car
Car rental in Israel, special prices
ג'רוזלם פוסט לייט
עיתון חדשות באנגלית קלה התורם לשיפור השפה האנגלית
Tour guides in Israel
Choose you’re your tour guide in Israel
Israel guide
Your guide to Israel
Green Israel
Protecting Israel's environment
ג'רוזלם פוסט לייט
עיתון חדשות באנגלית קלה התורם לשיפור השפה האנגלית


Middle East & Israel Breaking News » Opinion » Columnists » Article
SARAH HONIG SARAH HONIG

Another Tack: In awe and esteem


PrintSubscribe
Toolbar
+ Recommend:
facebook twitter del.icio.us reddit fark
What's this?

Decrease text size Decrease text size
Increase text size Increase text size
Article's topics: LaborLehiIrgunDavid Ben-gurionHosni MubarakBarack Obama 

Extreme acts are sometimes exonerated by history. When we view the world through our insular prism, we can easily lose perspective. Things may be swiftly magnified to grotesque proportions, like our trepidation of world censure, for instance. Frantically exaggerated anxieties then send us into a panic of self-reproach. Most often our self-inflicted alarm is unwarranted. Occasionally exploits sure to get Israel into hot water internationally may be the right thing to do. Losing our collective head isn't only unnecessary, it's downright harmful.

This was true even before our state was born, before we could be painted as an ogre imperialist Goliath, when we were history's most helpless underdogs. The world hardly empathized with us then either.

Exactly on this date 65 years ago - November 6, 1944 - two young Lehi fighters, 19-year-old Eliahu Hakim of Haifa and 22-year-old Tel Avivian Eliahu Beit-Zuri, assassinated Walter Edward Guinness, first Baron Moyne, in Cairo. He was the British minister resident in the Middle East. While the Holocaust was still ongoing, world opinion managed to expend more outrage on the two Eliahus, as they came to be known, than it did on their victim's appalling record.

The Labor-led Zionist establishment in pre-state Israel lost no time or vehemence in denouncing the assassination and launching what came to be dubbed the saison (the "hunting season" in which Lehi and Irgun members were pursued and turned over to the British). On November 20, 1944 David Ben-Gurion addressed the Histadrut convention and ordered the expulsion of "all Revisionists from all workplaces - be they in an office, factory or grove... the same goes for students in higher or secondary education, or any other school."

YET, INCREDIBLE as it sounds - given the strident anti-Israel incitement of Cairo's current state-run media under Hosni Mubarak's aegis - the Eliahus evoked widespread sympathy among Egyptians. Students demonstrated for them in the streets and rallied against sentencing them to death. Prominent Egyptian lawyers volunteered to represent them, adhered to the political defense decreed by the Eliahus and avidly espoused their nationalist Jewish sentiments.

Hakim set the tone: "We are the accusers at this trial. We accuse Lord Moyne and the government he represented of murdering hundreds of thousands of our brethren and usurping our homeland... Where is the law that would hold them answerable for their crimes? Though absent from the books, it is engraved in our hearts. Hence we had no alternative but to take justice into our own hands."

Like him, Beit-Zuri told the court: "Thousands of my people drowned in a sea of blood and tears. Nevertheless the British captain denied them haven. He stood on his deck and watched with equanimity how my people drown. And if, despite all, some managed to reach the boat and hang on to its sides, he - the British skipper - shoved them back down to make sure they sink into the abyss... For us, resident in our homeland, who witness all this, only one choice exists - surrender or fight. We choose to fight."

Lord Moyne had blood on his hands. He was personally responsible for inducing the Turks to tug the unseaworthy makeshift immigrant ship Struma - a pitiful rusty sardine-can of an antiquated Danube River barge - from Istanbul harbor on February 24, 1942. He thereby condemned nearly 800 Jewish refugees on board (including 103 children and babies) to a certain death. The disabled Struma was left paralyzed, without a motor, provisions or a drop of fuel, to drift precariously on the Black Sea. The Soviet torpedo that later struck it inadvertently was nothing but a coup de grace.

But there was more. On May 15, 1944 Budapest Jew Joel Brand was dispatched to Turkey by Adolf Eichmann (probably at Heinrich Himmler's behest) to propose exchanging a million Hungarian Jews for 10,000 trucks. It may well have been a cruel subterfuge, but the British treated the unfortunate Brand unconscionably. He was deceived, arrested and taken to Cairo where he was imprisoned for four-and-a-half months.

In his 1958 autobiography Advocate for the Dead, Brand described being interrogated by a British official, who he later learned was Lord Moyne himself. When told that the lives of as many as a million Jews might be at stake, Moyne retorted: "'What shall I do with those million Jews?' I couldn't bear to listen to him any further," Brand recounts. "I got up. If there's no place for us on this Earth, then Jews are forced into the gas chambers." At the 1961 Eichmann trial Brand repeated, under oath, his contention that the above dastardly remark was uttered by none other than Lord Moyne.

With the British pulling vassal Egypt's strings and agitating for capital punishment, the Eliahus stood no chance. They were sentenced to die by hanging. Hakim mounted the gallows first on March 22, 1945, singing "Hatikva" to his last breath. Beit-Zuri did the same half an hour later. Haider-Pasha, director-general of Egyptian prisons, who witnessed the executions, commented: "Today I saw two young lions die."

But despite the political purge, which the assassination facilitated, the Eliahus didn't remain vilified villains. Mainstream consensus is ever-mutable. The imperiously imposed axioms of the powers-that-be were eventually set aside.

Already in 1962, none other than Ben-Gurion wrote Lehi veteran Geula Cohen: "I bow down my head in awe and esteem for the heroic deaths of the two Eliahus in Cairo."

THEN CAME the post-Yom Kippur War negotiations with Egypt, when Israel officially requested the two Eliahus' remains. On June 26, 1975 they were accorded a state funeral in Jerusalem. On hand were prime minister Yitzhak Rabin, foreign minister Yigal Allon and other Labor stalwarts, some of them, like Rabin (as distinct from Allon), keen saison collaborators.

More than three decades after the executions, the British government seethed with fury. The Foreign Office, via British ambassador Sir Bernhard Ledwidge, shrilly protested "that an act of terrorism should be honored this way." The Rabin government rebuffed the petulant complaints. However, it stopped short of arguing that instead of demanding censure and collective contrition from Israelis for the assassination, London might express contrition for its policy of denying asylum to those who desperately tried to flee Hitler's hell.

Continued
1| 2 | Next»

RATE THIS ARTICLE
PrintSubscribe
Toolbar
+ Recommend:
facebook twitter del.icio.us reddit fark
What's this?
Post comment | Terms | Report Abuse
52. (My 4th Comment - continuation) For some reason, the word "Brand" won't print at the end of the third from last line of my comment, so there's a gap.
Joan Moira Peters - (11/17/2009 04:44)
51. Sarah lit a memorial candle and wowed me
Micha - Tel Adashim, Isarel (11/11/2009 11:07)
50. Superb column! Simply unforgettable.
Dolores Petruno - N.Y., U.S.A. (11/10/2009 15:34)
49. In awe - 2
Israel S. - Israel (11/09/2009 11:25)
48. In awe - 1
Israel S. - Israel (11/09/2009 11:13)
47. Daran (#40): read Yona (#36) and get enlightened
Alan - Canada (11/09/2009 11:05)
46. Thanks for the remembrance.
Delano - US: Institutes of the Criminally Insane (11/09/2009 10:44)
45. to # 41 - Why regurgitate nonsense you can't evaluate?
Lisa - Israel (11/09/2009 08:11)
44. Daran (#40): The Brits committed murder
AL - Israel (11/09/2009 07:58)
43. E & E
Neal - USA (11/09/2009 07:08)
42. Scandinavian Hater?
Tage Olson - Canada (11/09/2009 02:31)
41. My 3rd Comment. It was reportedly Lord Moyne who had UK Nazi Mosley's wife also interned. Britain was led in prayer while Nazis spread evil hatred.
Joan Moira Peters - (11/09/2009 01:41)
40. 3rd try This was an act of murder by a terror group not revenge, political act
Daran - UK (11/09/2009 00:35)
39. Inspiring, well said, important, timely article. The Europeans and English would rather kill than admit and face their shame.
Skip Kelley - USA (11/08/2009 20:49)
38. Moshe #1 No way...Amir is a nutcase..These two Eliu's killed a Jew hater!
fred M - usa (11/08/2009 19:11)
37. Sarah Honig, In Awe and Self-Esteem
Ben Manaster - USA (11/08/2009 17:32)
36. The Eliyahus were captured because they were principled (for #s 17 & 23)
Yona - Israel (11/08/2009 17:20)
35. To Joan #s 27 & 33 - superficial history
Naomi Misk - Israel (11/08/2009 17:12)
34. To Chava @ 23 - You are right
Drora Avivi - Israel (11/08/2009 15:38)
33. My 2nd Comment (cont.)There should have been a concerted effort by the international community to rescue Jews & others escaping the Holocaust.
Joan Moira Peters - (11/08/2009 15:23)
32. an inspiration, particularly to young jewish women like myself. G-d bless you
J - Israel (11/08/2009 15:00)
31. #27:Wikipedia is notoriously unreliable
Nick - Israel (11/08/2009 14:35)
30. To the "King of Israel' #8
Grant Freedom - USA (11/08/2009 14:15)
29. #17 - By your criteria Jews who defend themselves are villains
Izzy - Israel (11/08/2009 13:05)
28. Quislings of Yesteryear, Appeasers In History Can't Fathom What True Justice Entails.Those Who Point It Out Are Their Defacto Enemies. Astonishing...
Adina Kutnicki - Israel (11/08/2009 10:57)
27. During WW2 Brits feared increased immigration would fuel Nazi expansion in the Mideast through support for Hitler's associate, the Mufti of Jerusalem.
Joan Moira Peters - (11/08/2009 08:19)
26. Wonderful reminder of history. Be assured, This Christian loves Israel
Claudia - USA (11/08/2009 05:29)
25. Dislike by Barack Obama's US
Steve - USA (11/08/2009 03:49)
24. The Deed
Cry - (11/08/2009 01:30)
23. another possible piece of information
chava - (11/08/2009 00:15)
More...

LATEST STORIES BY SARAH HONIG

Most Original
eTeacher
Nefesh B'eNefesh
Kadish
JPost.com
KKL Picture of the week
Got a Question?
Have a question about something in this story? Ask it here and get answers from other users like you.

 
 
 
© 1995 - 2009 The Jerusalem Post. All rights reserved.    About Us | Media Kit | Exclusive Content | Advertise with Us | Subscribe | Contact Us | RSS
The online edition of The Jerusalem Post – JPost.com – provides first class news and analysis about Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world. Whether news about Iran, Gaza, Syria, Fatah, Hamas or Hezbollah, JPost.com covers the burning issues of the Middle East and the Israeli-Arab conflict.