Sticks & Stones and osteoporosis

Sticks & Stones and oste

By
November 8, 2009 05:34
osteoporosis

osteoporosis. (photo credit: )

 
X

Dear Reader,
As you can imagine, more people are reading The Jerusalem Post than ever before. Nevertheless, traditional business models are no longer sustainable and high-quality publications, like ours, are being forced to look for new ways to keep going. Unlike many other news organizations, we have not put up a paywall. We want to keep our journalism open and accessible and be able to keep providing you with news and analyses from the frontlines of Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish World.

As one of our loyal readers, we ask you to be our partner.

For $5 a month you will receive access to the following:

  • A user uxperience almost completely free of ads
  • Access to our Premium Section and our monthly magazine to learn Hebrew, Ivrit
  • Content from the award-winning Jerusalem Repor
  • A brand new ePaper featuring the daily newspaper as it appears in print in Israel

Help us grow and continue telling Israel’s story to the world.

Thank you,

Ronit Hasin-Hochman, CEO, Jerusalem Post Group
Yaakov Katz, Editor-in-Chief

UPGRADE YOUR JPOST EXPERIENCE FOR 5$ PER MONTH Show me later Don't show it again

If teenagers could see the future and observe the state of their own bones half a century ahead, they might be inspired to prevent osteoporosis with lifestyle and dietary changes to avoid disability and premature death. Almost all cases of thinning bones could be avoided if youngsters exercised regularly, maintained normal vitamin D levels and ate plenty of calcium. Prof. Anthony Sebba, an osteoporosis expert at the University of South Florida constantly sees middleaged and elderly people who when young did not follow that advice. "It's so frustrating. Osteoporosis is virtually preventible. If youngsters took this advice in time, they would be fine at the age of 80. Osteoporosis is almost a pediatric disease whose symptoms appear decades later," he says. "If every woman were assessed at 55, the risk would be brought down by 90 percent. It has no real symptoms; you don't feel it, so people are unaware that they have it unless they undergo a bone-density test. SEBBA, WHO was born in South Africa and comes from a long line of Lithuanian Jews, graduated for the University of Cape Town and completed his fellowship in rheumatology at Mount Sinai Medical Center in New York. He has been principal investigator in many osteoporosis studies and has lectured around the world on the the bone-thinning disease. The experienced rheumatologist, who recently visited Israel for the second time since arriving with a buddy after the Yom Kippur War, is here to present data at a conference on how a unique once-a-week pill combining 5,600 International Units (IUs) of vitamin D with alendronate sodium (biphosphonate) can help fight bone thinning. The bone resorption inhibitor drug, just put on the market by Merck, is called Fosavance, and combines the vital vitamin with the company's Fosamax (sold in Israel as Fosalan). Biphosphonates have been used for 100 years, originally to paint ship bottoms to repel barnacles; more recently, it has been utilized for coating the inside of metal pipes to prevent encrustation. But four decades ago, it was found to be good for promoting bone mass. In the past 13 years, some 55 million prescriptions of Fosamax have been penned by US doctors, but "it is a shrinking market despite the ageing of the population. There are no public service ads about the danger of bone thinning. People just don't understand the implications of not treating osteoporosis. If a person suffers from high blood pressure and osteoporosis, has no health insurance and can afford to pay for only one prescription, I tell him or her to treat the bone thinning, because failure to treat can be even more deadly. After five years of taking the drug, one can probably stop for several years if you have not broken a bone before," Sebba suggests. Alendronate sodium works by inhibiting the activity of cells called osteoclasts that cause bone loss. Osteoclasts remove old bone cells that are then replaced by new bone cells. In osteoporosis, osteoclasts continue to function normally but the bone cells removed are not replaced in enough volume to sustain normal bone density. Taking the drug reduces the amount of old bone cells that are removed. A year after a typical patient has a hip fracture and Sebba prescribes alendronate, only a quarter of them will still be taking it. Within a year of a hip fracture, as many as a third will die because of clots or other conditions. It's more effective to prevent fractures. Part of the compliance problem is that alendronate sodium must be taken on an empty stomach, swallowed only with tap water (not even mineral water or soda water), and the patient must be in an upright position for 30 minutes; if not, it could irritate the esophagus. It is a very safe drug, he stresses, but rare cases of damage to the jawbones and resulting dental problems have been connected to the taking of biphosphonate. ASKED IN a Jerusalem Post interview why the millions of Americans at risk from osteoporosis don't merely take cheap vitamin D drops (in water or juice) or tablets as well as alendronate sodium pills, Sebba explains: "Many people are too lazy or don't like to carry out their doctors' instructions. "There is very low compliance and too little awareness about the risks of vitamin D deficiency." Merck's combining the vitamin and biphosphonate was a major accomplishment, said Sebba, and taking the unified pill will make it easier for patients to follow doctors' advice. Biphosphonates had to be taken daily, but then once-a-week pills were marketed, and they are the most frequently prescribed. There is also a once-a-year zolendronic acid, which is similar to alendronate sodium but has to be administered as an infusion in a clinic instead of being taken orally. "There has to be an encounter with a doctor for this and it is more expensive than weekly pills, so most people prefer a pill. In addition, people tend to be apprehensive about an intravenous drug that once taken cannot be removed from the system or stopped. But the infusion is just as effective," Sebba says. In the US, milk and orange juice are fortified with vitamin D, but in Israel, unpopular 1%-fat milk is ANTHONY SEBBA: Half of all 50 year olds in the Western world will suffer a bone fracture before they die. The disease is more common among women than men because of the halt of estrogen production at menopause. required by law to have it but 3%-fat milk does not. Milk to which vitamin D and calcium are added is sold for a top price, even though the added components are cheap. "In my country, many people don't consume dairy products, including milk, because they are or think they are lactose intolerant," says Sebba. Tobacco smoking, by the way, promotes osteoporosis. Coffee makes drinkers lose calcium that is somewhat replaced if they add milk. It's better to get vitamin D naturally, as it's more easily produced in the skin or absorbed from food, but it's very hard to get in your diet, as it's found mostly in wild fish. So, says Sebba, people need a supplement. If they start with a deficiency of the vitamin, they will have to bring levels up to normal. It's easy to produce 5,000 units or so of vitamin D by exposing skin to the sun for just 20 minutes, declares the rheumatologist. "It doesn't matter what part of the body is exposed, or whether it's early in the morning with less intense sun. But one must be careful not to get sunburn." Israelis live in a country that is sunny most of the year, and vitamin D is produced in the skin from exposure to the sun. Since warnings about skin cancer from exposure to the sun's ultraviolet rays have induced many to stay in the shade, use sunscreen or spend most time indoors, and since ageing skin produces less vitamin D, many have vitamin D deficiencies. But Sebba says vitamin D deficiency in his southern state of Florida are as common as in Israel, mostly for the same reasons except for the very modest clothing warm by the observant. The lack of vitamin D in the blood and cells is at least partially responsible for a wide range of diseases and conditions, including rickets (soft, bent bones) and the tendency to fall, but osteoporosis is among the best known. He recommends that children and adults of all ages - and not only infants, as officially recommended in Israel - take vitamin D daily. Age and condition determines the amount needed. Taking calcium pills to increase bone density, he says, is "probably less important than people think. This mineral is necessary but not sufficient to prevent or treat bone thinning. Vitamin D is much more important. It may take a decade or more to educate the American or Israeli public on the importance of the vitamin. I test almost all my patients for the vitamin, and maybe five percent have normal levels. It is the most common vitamin deficiency. Of course, they have come after having a fracture or from concern that they have osteoporosis, but the problem is common in the general population. I myself take 2,000 IUs a day." Although it is fat soluble and thus is stored in body fat, it is almost impossible to have a toxic amount. Half of all 50 year olds in the Western world will suffer a bone fracture before they die, Sebba states. The disease is more common among women than men because of the halt of estrogen production at menopause, but males too - especially if they have low testosterone levels - can suffer from osteoporosis. "Women live longer than men on average, but if men lived as long as women, they would have more fractures," says Sebba. In addition, people who take certain drugs such as corticosteroids on a long-term basis can lose a lot of bone mass. A bone density test - a painless, low-radiation mini-X-ray of a section of the spine and hip or wrist, is cheap in the US, so even Americans lacking health insurance can probably afford it. Women at menopause and men at 70 should undergo a test for a baseline density reading, Sebba recommends, but it should be earlier if they previously had a fracture or osteoporosis runs in the family. After the baseline is established, their doctors will recommend whether to treat and how often to re-test. Asked whether having large or broad bones means one is protected from bone thinning, the rheumatologist said no. "The bone can be broad, but it can still have low density." Ironically, obese people are more protected against bone fractures than the thin, even if they have osteoporosis, because "if they fall down, they have protective padding." JUST A random sample of bone density can be taken, continues Sebba. "It wouldn't matter whether a toe or leg bone is tested. But we usually focus on the spine and hip because fractures are most common there, and we get a direct reading of sites more likely to fracture. Any fracture in postmenopausal woman that resulted from a low-impact fall or other trauma is, in my book, a sign of osteoporosis. When I hear about such a fracture, I say it's osteoporosis unless proven otherwise. If a person slips and falls, a bone fracture should not occur." Exercise "helps phenomenally to build up bone mass up to the age of 20. It is somewhat less effective until 50, says Sebba, and when exercise is begun after that, "the effectiveness is a lot less clear, at least in my view. But exercise itself does reduce falls, promote better balance and make people stronger." Kids fracture their bones from time to time, and they recover. As a result, adults don't realize how dangerous fractures can be. Most spinal fractures occur without people being aware of them. Those who lose height over the years are likely to have osteoporosis and undiagnosed spinal fractures. Their spine is shorter, and they are bent over, causing internal organs to be pushed together, making them tired and respiration more difficult. If they are bent over, they can't see where they are going as well, and are at higher risk of falling. It they had been treated in time, their height would not have declined." Sebba concludes that it was probably his South African-born grandmother who led him into researching osteoporosis. "She had dementia at the end, but she lived with serious disability for nine years after she broke a hip. If she had not suffered a fracture, she surely would have had a better life."

Related Content

[illustrative photo]
September 24, 2011
Diabetes may significantly increase risk of dementia

By UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN HEALTH SYSTEM