The oldest excuse in the world
When a society can’t explain its failures, it finds a Jew. The libel used to wear a yellow badge. Now it wears a tie.
In Michigan’s 2026 Senate race, a PAC ad showed a couple putting back the eggs because $7 goes to “killing Palestinians.” Price of groceries in Detroit? Set in Jerusalem.
At the UN Human Rights Council, Israel holds the only permanent agenda item. It has been condemned more often than Syria, North Korea, and Iran combined.
The reflex now comes with a price tag. In September 2025, the European Commission moved to strip Israeli goods of preferential market access and sanction Israeli ministers.
By April 2026, Spain and Ireland were demanding outright suspension of the EU-Israel Association Agreement. The Jew among the nations is to be punished through his wallet.
The Jews of the Jews
Inside Israel, it is the same script. The haredim (ultra-Orthodox) play the role the world assigns to us: parasites, shirkers, breeders, budget-drains. From a European’s mouth, every one of those charges would be called antisemitism. From one Jew about another, it passes for policy.
Since the High Court’s June 2024 ruling, the state has cut funding to 1,257 yeshivas and pulled daycare subsidies from 6,700 families.
Equality, they call it, though nobody cuts the daycare of the secular kid who walks out through the mental-health officer or the conscientious objector or the Arab citizen.
The target was never the exemption. It is the Torah world itself: the community that gives Israel its above-replacement birthrate, that built Yad Sarah, Ezer Mizion, United Hatzalah, and Zaka, that carried the Jewish people for 2,000 years without a state or an army.
The same sanctions, twice
Put the two campaigns side by side. Same playbook, same calendar.
In late 2025, the High Court gave the state 45 days to impose economic sanctions on haredim who don’t enlist. Within weeks, the European Commission moved to suspend trade concessions on €5.8 billion of Israeli exports.
In the spring of 2026, the High Court ordered ministries to strip draft-age men, four in five of them haredi, of daycare, transit discounts, municipal-tax relief, and subsidized housing. Days later, Spain and Ireland demanded the EU suspend its Association Agreement with Israel.
The details dovetail. The Knesset’s draft bills bar yeshiva students from leaving the country or getting a driver’s license. Brussels drafts travel-ban lists for Israeli ministers.
Israel yanks these families from its discount housing lotteries, the cost half a million shekels per apartment. Europe threatens to yank Israel’s preferential market access.
Same premise both times: this people’s seat at the table is a privilege, revocable until they “behave.” Cheer the second set of sanctions, and you’ve lost every argument against the first.
Measure for measure
A secularist calls this coincidence. The Torah calls it a covenant, and a covenant has two sides.
In Leviticus 26: Walk in My statutes and “I will grant peace in the land.” Spurn them and your enemies rule over you.
In Deuteronomy 28: Keep the mitzvahs and “all the peoples of the Earth shall see that the name of Hashem is called upon you, and they shall fear you.” Abandon them, and Israel becomes a byword.
The Rambam opens Hilchot Ta’aniyot (Law of Fasts) with the ruling: a community struck by calamity must trace it to its deeds. To shrug it off as chance is cruelty.
Attack the men who learn the Torah and their families, and you attack the Torah itself. Attack the Torah, and you attack the God of Israel who gave it. When a Jewish state makes that its policy, the other side of the Covenant kicks in, measure for measure.
Israel calls the Jews who sit and learn parasites; the nations call Israel a parasite. Israel drafts sanctions for Bnei Brak; Brussels drafts them for Israel. The numbers track: 1,821 antisemitic incidents in America in 2004. Then 9,354 in 2024, the very year the Court ordered the yeshivas drafted and defunded.
The questions nobody runs on
The scapegoat has an earthly use too. It swallows every question Israel’s governing class would rather not answer.
Natural gas. The Tax Authority projects the Citizens of Israel Fund will collect $60-$75 billion over the life of the offshore reserves. The total 2026 payout: NIS 235.6 million, about NIS 23 per citizen. Alaska mails every resident a dividend. Israel’s gas hasn’t lowered one family’s electric bill.
Cars. Purchase tax, customs, and VAT stack up to 113-128% of a car’s value, a wall built to protect an auto industry that folded decades ago. An Israeli family car becomes a luxury item.
KKL. Keren Kayemeth LeIsrael-Jewish National Fund owns 13% of the country’s land and pocketed a record NIS 6.8 billion from land sales in 2022.
The State Comptroller’s first-ever audit, in 2017, found barely a third of that revenue going to public projects, and the state’s supervisory committee hadn’t met since the 1970s. Where the rest goes, nobody can say.
The High Court. The sanctions on yeshivas were never legislated. They were ordered by judges, and an attorney-general whom no voter chose and no voter can remove.
Sitting justices held a built-in majority on the committee that picks their successors. The attorney-general’s powers appear in no statute, yet since 1993 her opinions bind the government she advises.
A body that selects itself, defines its own jurisdiction, and strikes down the laws meant to limit it answers to no one.
Housing. The state sits on 93% of the land. A stack of ministries, authorities, and committees takes an average of 13 years to move a home from plan to key: 11 of them paperwork, two of them construction.
Bank Leumi’s CEO pegs the bureaucracy tax at nearly a 10th of the price of an apartment. Having manufactured the shortage, the state rations what’s left as a reward for compliance and tells the young couple who can’t afford a home that the yeshiva is to blame.
The bet
Scapegoating the haredim has not lowered a single tax, filled a single tank crew, or made a single Jew abroad safer. It has shown Brussels how to draft sanctions against Jews, and by the Torah’s account, it has done worse: it has invited those sanctions.
The Jew-haters have always needed a Jew to blame. The tragedy is that Israel has decided it needs one too, and has chosen those Jews who sit and learn.
The Torah’s promise is simple: stop turning on the Torah and those who keep it, and the view of us from outside changes. That covenantal bet is worth making. The other bet is being lost in front of our eyes.
The writer is an attorney in Jerusalem and principal of David Page Law, a full-service law firm with an emphasis on real estate, wills, trusts, and estates. He has taught law at the Hebrew University at the Faculty of Law and made aliyah after a judicial clerkship and a year in Washington DC’s largest law firm. He is also a member of R’ Daniel Belsky’s Kollel and the author of Rav Gustman, on the Rosh Yeshiva who was the last Dayan of Vilna, and the creator of the podcast The Kings of Israel.