MAURICE SAMUELS New Haven The writer is director of the Yale Program for the Study of AntisemitismBaths of ages Sir, – Melanie Lidman’s article on the inauguration of the Ophel City Walls Site (“First Temple period archeological site unveiled in Jerusalem,” June 22) is somewhat misleading. While the monumental architecture at the site indeed dates to the First Temple period, the “multiple mikvot” (Jewish ritual baths) found nearby date to no earlier than the late Second Temple period. Consequentially, there is no basis for her suggestion that the name of the “Water Gate” mentioned in Nehemia 3:26 relates to “the plethora of mikvot in the area.”YONATAN ADLER Jerusalem
The writer recently completed his doctorate in the Department of Land of Israel Studies and Archaeology at Bar-Ilan University
Melanie Lidman responds: While there are many mikvot in the area around the Old City walls from the Second Temple period, there is also a variety of mikvot inside the new complex inaugurated this week that date to the First Temple period. The future “Promenade of Mikvot” planned by the East Jerusalem Development Company will create a link between mikvot from all the periods in history. The connection to the verse in Nehemia was made by the archaeologist, Dr. Eilat Mazar, and not by me.Abort the initiative Sir, – Daoud Kuttab (“The morning after the UN vote,” Comment & Features, June 21) has it all wrong. The day after the Palestinians unilaterally declare statehood in the UN it will be Israel that acts.Foreign Minister Lieberman recently stated that Israel will void the Oslo Accords, for example. This will have the effect of gelding the brazen Palestinian Authority cold. The tactic of withholding PA tax funds has also come up. This would have a devastating effect on its ability to function on any plane.A proposal has also been raised in the Knesset to annex the lands in Judea and Samaria on which Jewish settlements are located. This would effectively eviscerate the Palestinian state.In my view, the Palestinian statehood initiative at the UN is so hostile that it’s essentially a declaration of war.Kuttab would be well advised to climb on the bandwagon of logic, rationality and truth and tell PA President Mahmoud Abbas to abort the whole initiative. Negotiations are the only path to a permanent settlement.YONATAN SILVERMAN Tel Aviv