Some truths about Palestinian Christians

Christians suffered most in West Bank, where Muslim refugees were cynically settled in their midst.

pope rock star bethlehem 248 88 (photo credit: AP)
pope rock star bethlehem 248 88
(photo credit: AP)
Palestinian and other Arab Christians are a perennial political football, especially with Pope Benedict XVI's visit to the Holy Land. Seen by some as the epitome of what happens to minorities under Islamist rule (when their shops are firebombed in Hamas-run Gaza), they are also continually used by the Western media to show how the Israeli security fence divides those in Bethlehem from Jerusalem. Even as their community shrinks they seem to get more and more attention. They were a centerpiece of Jimmy Carter's Palestine: Peace not Apartheid. It is worthwhile therefore to consider a little about their recent history and dispel some of the myths that have grown up about them. A recent Time magazine article by Andrew Lee Butters notes that "the creation of Israel has been a disaster for Christians in the Middle East. Many of the Palestinian refugees... were Christians. The flood of Palestinian refugees into Lebanon helped spark a civil war between Muslims and Christians there... the ongoing occupation of the West Bank [by Israel] is strangling the life out of those Christian communities that are left." The truth is quite different. There were roughly 150,000 Arab Christians in British mandatory Palestine on the eve of Israel's 1948 War of Independence. Some 75,685 fled the areas that became Israel, leaving 32,000 in Israel in 1949, mostly in Nazareth, some villages in the Galilee and in Haifa, Acre and Jaffa. Family reunification and repatriation programs brought their numbers to 39,000 by 1951. Most Christian refugees came from Jaffa, Haifa and West Jerusalem, and almost all of them fled before Israel declared independence in May 1948. In fact Ben-Gurion ordered the IDF to give special protection to Nazareth when it was seized on July 16: "Those who penetrate into the city will fight valiantly against invaders and gangs wherever they resist; at the same time they will meticulously and conscientiously refrain from harming, despoiling or pillaging holy places." Christian villages in the Galilee, many of which are also shared with Druze, were given special protective treatment as well, and few were harmed by Israelis or abandoned by their Christian inhabitants. CHRISTIANS ACTUALLY benefited demographically from the creation of Israel, rising from 1 in 7 of the Arab population to 1 in 3 by the 1950s. Rather than being "many" of the refugees, they formed a small minority and fared much better than their Muslim counterparts. Most were middle class, educated and spoke foreign languages. Because of this, prominent Palestinian Christians such as the families of Edward Said and John Sanunu (Ronald Reagan's chief of staff) easily assimilated in the West. Their being overwhelmingly urban - in 1947 115,000 lived in towns and cities - made them both vulnerable during the war and also made it easier to flee the fighting. Christian communities suffered most in the West Bank, where Muslim refugees were cynically settled in their midst. Thus Ramallah was 90% Christian before the war and contained only 5,000 inhabitants, while Bethlehem was 80% Christian and had only 9,000 inhabitants. By 1967 there were 16,000 people in Bethlehem, of whom only 6,400 were Christian, and Ramallah is a large Muslim city today. Lebanon was certainly harmed by the influx of Palestinian refugees, but its Christians were hurt primarily as a result of the 1970 Jordanian Civil War, after which Arafat's PLO created a state within a state in Lebanon and, in alliance with other Muslim militias, destabilized the country. Far from "strangling the life" out of Christian communities in the West Bank, where there are barely 50,000 Christians, access to Israel and its economy, education and medical facilities helped them. In contrast the Hamas victory in Gaza after the Israeli withdrawal hasn't made their life better. Compared to Christians in the Palestinian territories, the ones in Israel have flourished even though demographically they have declined to 2% of the population. THE OTHER SIDE of the story of Palestinian Christians is that they have had a long and hallowed role in Arab nationalism. Mathilda Moghannem, a Protestant Palestinian feminist, declared in January 1948 that "Christians will become Muslims to defeat Zionism." George Habash, founder and leader of the communist terrorist PFLP, was a Christian, as was Yasser Arafat's wife. In the 1970s a Catholic Christian priest, Hilarion Carucci, was even convicted of running guns for the PLO. Palestinian Christians suffer periodic bouts of intimidation and harassment. Their churches are spray-painted with graffiti, and while Christian women marry Muslim men and Palestinian law ensures their children must be raised Muslim, when a Christian man is rumored to date a Muslim women riots have ensued. Larry Derfner recently wrote in The Jerusalem Post that they are a "minority that tends to get along... [and] keep their complaints to themselves" and that attacks on them may reflect "class resentment." Such talk about minorities might remind us of how these were supposed to behave as dhimmi under Islamism, or how the Jews lived in Europe before the Holocaust. People resented the Jews' class as well - hardly an excuse to attack and harass them. The writer, a PhD student in geography at the Hebrew University, wrote his M.A. thesis there on Arab Christians. A contributor to various publications, he runs the Terra Incognita Journal blog.