Many of us are used to looking at the "amount of sugar" in a product as the sole measure of health or weight loss. But the truth is, our body is not a simple chemical lab, and it does not treat every gram of sugar the same way. If we compare onion, carrot, and strawberry, for example – we’ll find that they all contain almost the same amount of sugar (about 5%), yet their effect on blood sugar levels and satiety is completely different.
For Dr. Maya Rosman’s online diet course, click here
Note – this is the sugar content per 100 grams:
Carrot – about 4.5–5% sugar. Most of the sugar is sucrose and glucose.
This is considered relatively high for a vegetable, which is why carrots taste sweet even when raw.
Strawberries – about 4.5–5% sugar. In other words – very similar to carrots.
Even though they are fruit, strawberries are considered low in sugar compared to most fruits.
Onion – about 4–6% sugar, depending on the variety and freshness. Cooking and roasting reduce the sharp compounds in onion, making its natural sweetness much more noticeable.
The big difference lies in how the sugar is packaged within the food. This is where three critical factors come into play, determining whether the food spikes insulin or nourishes us over time:
1. Type of Fiber: “The Protective Layer”
Dietary fiber is not just “for good digestion”; it is the gatekeeper of sugar.
In carrots and onions: There is a high presence of insoluble fiber (like cellulose). These are tough fibers that create a physical network inside the intestine. To reach the sugar inside the cells, the body’s enzymes need to “work hard” and break down the fibrous structure.
In strawberries: Most fibers are soluble (like pectin). They do create a gel-like texture that slows absorption, but because the strawberry is very soft, food breakdown in the mouth and stomach is much faster than in a hard root vegetable.
2. Rate of Sugar Absorption (Glycemic Index)
The question is not how much sugar enters, but how fast. When we eat raw carrot, the extensive chewing and tough cell structure cause sugar to be released into the blood “drip by drip.” Moreover, it was previously thought that carrot (especially cooked) had a very high glycemic index (around 80–90). More recent studies show that raw carrot is in the 16–35 range (very low), and cooked carrot is in the 33–49 range (still considered low).
Since 100 grams of carrot contains only about 5 grams of sugar/available carbohydrate, its glycemic load is very low (around 2). In other words, to achieve a significant blood sugar spike, a person would need to eat an enormous amount of carrot at once.
By contrast, fruits (even low-sugar ones like strawberries) are usually eaten more quickly, and their sugar is more readily available for absorption. This is why root vegetables are considered a “complex carbohydrate” within a vegetable package, whereas fruit is considered a more readily available energy unit.
3. The “Together” Effect: Combinations in a Meal
It’s rare for someone to eat half a kilo of raw onion as a snack. Onion is usually eaten as part of a meal – in a salad with olive oil, in a soup, or in a stew.
The combination wins: When we eat onion or carrot alongside protein (egg/cheese) or fat (tahini/olive oil), the rate of stomach emptying slows even more. This reduces the glycemic index of the entire meal to almost zero.
Why is strawberry a “fruit” and carrot a “free vegetable”?
Despite the similar raw data, metabolic behavior determines the classification:
Strawberry: Eaten in larger quantities (a 300-gram basket is a common serving), so in the “quantity test” it ultimately provides a carbohydrate amount equivalent to a fruit serving. The fruit is soft and easily digested, and the sugar is absorbed relatively quickly.
Carrot and onion: Thanks to the tough texture, the need for extensive chewing, and their role in the menu as part of a larger dish, they hardly affect blood sugar levels in a healthy person. And if you want the strawberries to have less impact too – combine them with 3% fat yogurt or with other protein/fat sources (like nuts and almonds) to reduce the glycemic index; in such cases, they are excellent at any time, even for those prone to diabetes.