Combined stages of Gaza war to take several months; thousands of Hamas terrorists killed

This could mean a mix of some months of all-out fighting, followed by a significant number of additional months fighting against an insurgency after the initial “victory.”

 Israeli soldiers ride in an armoured personnel carrier (APC), amid the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas, near the border between Israel and Gaza Strip, in Israel, October 31, 2023. (photo credit: REUTERS/AMIR COHEN)
Israeli soldiers ride in an armoured personnel carrier (APC), amid the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas, near the border between Israel and Gaza Strip, in Israel, October 31, 2023.
(photo credit: REUTERS/AMIR COHEN)

The combined stages of the current invasion and the expected later stages of insurgency and lower-grade fighting will take several months, informed sources have told The Jerusalem Post.

While to date, the IDF and top political officials have talked about an invasion lasting more than weeks, and other processes lasting a couple of months or more, the impression now is that it will take longer.

This will probably not mean several months of intense fighting like now, but rather a combination of strategies, followed by months of fighting an insurgency after the initial stage.

There may also not be any one marker day for an end to the fighting, as Hamas is not expected to surrender at any point. Instead, the expectation is that just as over the past week, ground forces escalated their fighting, at some later point, the scale of fighting will be gradually reduced.

Beyond several months, it is hard for the IDF to predict. Given that insurgencies in Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan lasted years, the estimate right now is several months.

  Preparations by the IDF for ground operations in the Gaza Strip. (credit: IDF SPOKESPERSON'S UNIT)
Preparations by the IDF for ground operations in the Gaza Strip. (credit: IDF SPOKESPERSON'S UNIT)
Unclear how Many are hiding in tunnels

This is probably due to the methodical pace of IDF forces, which are mostly still based in northern Gaza, and Hamas’s avoidance of too many large-scale battles, as they wait patiently to spring ambushes.

Thousands of Hamas terrorists have been killed by the IDF, some 1,500 during the first few days. Some tens of thousands of Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad forces remain in Gaza.

It is unclear how many are still in northern Gaza, hiding in tunnels, hospitals, mosques, and other civilian locations, and how many have been evacuated to southern Gaza, including more than one million Palestinians from Gaza City.But the number who have left has helped give the IDF a freer hand to act.

The military has used six different methods to encourage evacuation: phone calls, text messages, fliers, social media, public media calls, and occasionally “roof-knocking,” which includes the firing of a missile to bang loudly on a roof – without exploding – to scare and motivate civilians to evacuate, after earlier warnings are ignored.

Morale is high, despite losses

The IDF and political officials have said there is less roof-knocking in this war, simply because it intends the complete elimination of Hamas, so the surprise factor is critical.

Soldiers’ morale is considered very high and even more impressive than many commanders and Israeli society had expected from the younger generation. Some of that motivation is also highly personal.

The IDF has acknowledged that it is taking some heavy hits, including ambushes against an armored personnel carrier and a tank, but this is expected in urban war, and generally, the losses have been low given the challenging urban invasion setting. Hamas has fired hundreds of anti-tank missiles at IDF forces, mostly without success.

The military is conscious of the multifront nature of the conflict. It believes that hitting Hamas with unprecedented power in the South will restore deterrence in the North against the threat of Hezbollah, but said it is also ready if Hezbollah decides to escalate.

US support has been critical in restocking weaponry, in projecting power to other regional adversaries, and in offering useful advice for fighting in urban settings. But the IDF rejects any claims that American military personnel do anything more than give advice, which it can choose to accept or reject.