French Jews concerned over Macron's Israel 'killing women and children in Gaza' comments

French Jews, who have been suffering from a huge wave of antisemitism, added: "The CRIF would like to remind everyone of Hamas's responsibility for the deaths of Palestinian civilians."

 French President Emmanuel Macron gestures as he speaks during an international humanitarian conference for civilians in Gaza, at the Elysee Presidential Palace, in Paris, France, on November 9, 2023. (photo credit: LUDOVIC MARIN/POOL VIA REUTERS)
French President Emmanuel Macron gestures as he speaks during an international humanitarian conference for civilians in Gaza, at the Elysee Presidential Palace, in Paris, France, on November 9, 2023.
(photo credit: LUDOVIC MARIN/POOL VIA REUTERS)

"The CRIF has expressed concern regarding the remarks made by the President of the Republic in his interview with the BBC," the umbrella organization for French Jewry said in a tweet on Saturday night. French President Emmanuel Macron said on Friday that Israel is killing women and children in Gaza, in an interview he gave to the BBC at his official residence.

"De facto - today civilians are being bombed," Macron claimed. "These babies, these women, these old people are being bombed and killed. So there is no reason for it and no legitimacy. So we do plead with Israel to stop."

Wave of antisemitism washes over France

French Jews, who have been suffering from a huge wave of antisemitism, added: "The CRIF would like to remind everyone of Hamas's responsibility for the deaths of Palestinian civilians. Hamas has not only dragged these civilians into this war but is also using them as human shields today.

"This statement, by implying Israel's responsibility for civilian deaths, which are undoubtedly regrettable, potentially enables groups like LFI [a left-wing populist party in France] to exploit the situation, thereby stoking tensions and dividing France.

A demonstrator holds a placard depicting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, U.S. President Joe Biden, French President Emmanuel Macron and Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant during a protest in support of Palestinians in Gaza, as the conflict between Israel and Palestinian terroris group  (credit: YVES HERMAN/REUTERS)
A demonstrator holds a placard depicting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, U.S. President Joe Biden, French President Emmanuel Macron and Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant during a protest in support of Palestinians in Gaza, as the conflict between Israel and Palestinian terroris group (credit: YVES HERMAN/REUTERS)

"The onus for civilian casualties in Gaza rests with Hamas, not Israel. Similarly, the responsibility for civilian deaths in Raqqa or Mosul was with the Islamic State, not France.

"Furthermore, the call for a ceasefire, without mentioning the release of hostages, including 8 French nationals, potentially sidelines France's stance from that of other major democratic countries, which support Israel's essential struggle against Hamas," the CRIF stated firmly. 

"The CRIF is requesting a clarification of France's position," they concluded.

The French president also said that a ceasefire would benefit Israel, but added that Paris recognizes Israel's right to defend itself.

He emphasized that France "clearly condemns" the terrorist actions of Hamas. When asked if he wanted other leaders - including in the United States and Great Britain - to join his calls for a ceasefire, he replied: "I hope so." Jerusalem has since rejected calls for a ceasefire.

A French diplomatic source asked to explain that Macron's statement was misinterpreted."While his views have not changed, President Macron acknowledges as everyone that the situation on ground is evolving and that the number of civilian collateral casualties in Gaza is increasing at a rapid pace," the source said on Saturday. "His answers to the BBC questions merely recalled the unbearable nature of innocent human beings’ suffering, in this case in Gaza. He has been expressing his deepest grief and sorrow for the Israeli victims, in many other interviews. 

"President Macron never implied and does not think, that Israeli forces are deliberately targeting civilians. He has been consistently qualifying Hamas’ use of hostages or civilian population as 'unacceptable blackmail.'"

The diplomatic source explained why Macron won't participate in Sunday's march against antisemitism in France. "Since the start of his mandate, President Macron has never attended any single march, regardless of their importance and vital nature. He believes that his role as head of State is to speak up about the core values of the French Republic, among which are fraternity and tolerance. He has been consistently repeating that the French authorities will fight relentlessly against antisemitism and acting as such. He has called on all members of the French government to attend the march, which he called 'a beacon of hope'. The Prime Minister and many ministers will attend, as will the President 'in heart and mind.'"

 GUY ALISTAIR/WALLA! and JERUSALEM POST STAFF contributed to this report.