View From the Hills: UN, ‘Unwanted Nobodies’
10/23/2012 21:55
Sure there is a bloody conflict here in the Middle East – but it’s not between Jerusalem and Ramallah, but to the north in Syria.
Ulpana outpost near Beit El Photo: REUTERS/Nir Elias
Every Wednesday and Thursday morning is an adventure as I commute during morning
rush hour from Gush Etzion to Beit-El in the Binyamin Region to host my
talk-radio program.
The entire route – which begins on Highway 60 in the
Gush, crosses through Jerusalem lengthwise passing the Old City on Highway 1,
and then re-links to 60 via the Ramallah Bypass Road toward Beit-El – usually
takes just over an hour. While traffic is at times at a standstill, especially
in Jerusalem, the trip is always meaningful as the road literally follows the
path of our Patriarchs, and with it thousands of years of Jewish
history.
However, I’ve often noticed other motorists on the road over the
years calmly navigating in their snow-white vehicles marked with blue insignia
and the letters “UN,” who merge onto Highway 1 just past the Old
City.
These travelers proceed to follow a nearly identical route, with
the only difference being that they always turn off the road just before Beit-
El and enter PA-controlled Ramallah via the “DCO Checkpoint” reserved for
diplomats, dignitaries and other VIPs.
While I’ve never engaged in
conversation with these people, it’s most likely that they are members of the
Jerusalem-based United Nations Truce Supervision Organization (UNTSO),
established in 1948 and whose stated purpose according to their website is to
serve as mediators of the truce between Israel and the Arabs and specifically to
act “as gobetweens for the hostile parties and as the means by which isolated
incidents could be contained and prevented from escalating into major
conflicts.”
On paper it sounds like a noble cause. But upon further
examination it seems that the only thing this group is doing is contributing to
Israel’s carbon monoxide levels with all of their back-and-forth illusory
“shuttle altruism.”
Sure there is a bloody conflict here in the Middle
East – but these days it’s not between Jerusalem and Ramallah, but to the north
in Syria.
According to the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human
Rights monitoring group, violence in Syria has claimed the lives of 33,082
people over the past 18 months. That can be broken down into 8,211 soldiers
killed along with 1,241 army defectors who joined the insurgency against Syrian
President Bashar Assad.
The monitoring group says the death toll by far
has been highest among civilians, with an astonishing 23,630 dead. Those numbers
do not include unidentified victims or people who have “gone missing,” presumed
to have been either arrested by the regime, or perhaps killed.
So with
all of that bloodshed, instead of turning in to Ramallah, why not continue north
to the Golan and into Syria and try to do some real good by saving lives there?
One could argue that the UN did try to strive for calm in Syria. In April, the
UN Security Council passed a resolution calling for the establishment of an
envoy known as UNSMIS to travel to Syria in order to “monitor a cessation of
armed violence in all its forms by all parties and to monitor and support the
full implementation of the Joint Special Envoy’s six-point plan to end the
conflict in Syria.” After 90 days and an additional 30-day extension, with only
rare lulls in the violence, UNSMIS was shut down for failing to meet its
goals.
In addition, according to the most recent news reports, UN Arab
League envoy to Syria Lakhdar Brahimi has put together plans for the deployment
of a 3,000-member peacekeeping force to try and end the conflict.
But so
far that plan is all talk as Brahimi, who took over for former UN Chief Kofi
Annan after Annan failed to make any progress, has spent weeks just figuring out
which countries will be involved. All of this while at the Security Council
itself, meaningful sanctions against the Syrian leadership have failed to pass
with Russia and China blocking three attempts to pass harsh
resolutions.
The situation remains bleak, but it seems that none of the
UN-affiliated bodies in Israel or throughout the PA are willing or will be given
a mandate to get involved.
But I would hate for anyone even for a second
to believe the UN was here busy doing anything worthwhile to protect Israel. In
fact, over the past few days, while Israelis in the southern part of the country
have been once again forced to live in or near bomb shelters as rockets rain
down from Gaza, not a single UN body has condemned the attacks.
Internet
search results for “Israel” over the past 45 days on the UN News Center website
do not turn up even one article focusing on or condemning the rocket
attacks.
While there is silence over the rockets (and missiles), the UN’s
Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs in the “Occupied”
Palestinian territory continues to offer a detailed weekly megilah, or scroll,
listing alleged violence by Israeli soldiers, and of course “settlers,” against
Arabs.
The report even includes a score-card of the number of
Palestinians killed in a given week in Gaza and the West Bank. But details of
their deaths – including cases where would-be terrorists are killed in IDF
operations to prevent large-scale attacks, are conveniently omitted.
To
be fair, in one recent weekly report, a line buried at the bottom does say that
“Palestinian armed factions fired dozens of projectiles towards southern
Israel,” but it mentions that fact (almost in passing) only after stating that
they were fired “following [an Israeli] air strike,” as if launching rockets at
Israeli civilians was a justified response to IDF pinpoint strikes for the
purpose of self-defense.
So let’s call a spade a spade. Whether in the
General Assembly, the Security Council, or more specifically in any of the
UN-bodies based in this part of the world, it would seem fair, as written on a
classic bumper sticker seen throughout this country, to state: “UN, Unwanted
Nobodies, go home (or go to Syria).”
The writer is a media analyst,
freelance journalist, children’s author, and host of Reality Bytes Radio, on
www.israelnationalradio.com.